Number of Volumes 5
Number of Issues 13
Number of Articles 179
Number of Contributors 463
Article View 97,722
PDF Download 37,495
View Per Article 545.93
PDF Download Per Article 209.47
 
Acceptance Rate 25
Time to Accept (Days) 119
Number of Indexing Databases 7
Number of Reviewers 59

Journal of New Approaches in Management and Marketing is an open-access, double-blind, peer-reviewed publication published by the Research Center of Resource Management Studies and Knowledge-Based Business. 

JNAMM is a quarterly publication that publishes original research papers related to the journal's scope. This journal follows the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) and complies with the highest ethical standards by ethical laws. All submitted manuscripts are checked for similarity through SamimeNoor software to ensure their authenticity to be assured about its originality and then rigorously peer-reviewed by expert reviewers. (Read More...)


Main Features of the Journal:
  • Owner: Research Center for Management Studies and Knowledge-Based Business
  • Publication Frequency: Quarterly (The journal started quarterly publication from Spring 2024)
  • Article Types: Research and Review Articles
  • Language: Persian, with English Abstract
  • Peer Review: Double-blind
  • Specialization Areas: Marketing Management, Business, Entrepreneurship
  • Initial Review Time for Articles: 10 days
  • Publication Type: Electronic
  • Processing and Publication Fee: No
  • Start of Publication: October 2022
  • Access to Articles: Open Access
Original Article (Qualitative) Marketing Management

Designing a model for the transformation of B2B marketing strategies based on artificial intelligence in small and medium-sized companies

Pages 1-18

https://doi.org/10.22034/jnamm.2026.579440.1273

parna khaleghi zanjani, Gholamreza Tizfahm Fard, Sahar Mola zeinali, MAHMOUD SAMADI

Abstract Abstract The present study aimed to design a transformation model for AI-based B2B marketing strategies in small and medium-sized enterprises. In terms of purpose, this research is applicable, and was conducted through a qualitative approach based on the grounded theory strategy. The research population consisted of marketing managers and artificial intelligence experts. Sampling was carried out by a purposive method, and the data collection process continued until theoretical saturation was achieved, which was ultimately reached after 15 in-depth interviews. Data analysis was conducted in three stages—open, axial, and selective coding—through MAXQDA18 software. The findings indicated that causal factors, including the necessity of analyzing competitive big data, changes in the decision-making patterns of organizational buyers, and pressure to reduce marketing costs, play a key role in initiating this transformation. Contextual factors, including the organization’s digital maturity and the quality of data infrastructure, provide the necessary foundation for the successful implementation of intelligent marketing, while limitations in financial resources, technical complexities, and resistance from traditional sales experts act as intervening factors. According to the results, adopting strategies such as the implementation of intelligent account management systems, predictive analytics, and content automation leads to improved outcomes such as higher return on investment, increased loyalty among key customers, and reduced sales cycles. This study provides a systematic framework that helps managers of small enterprises gain a sustainable competitive advantage in industrial markets by understanding the complex interactions between artificial intelligence tools and marketing strategies. Introduction Today, artificial intelligence has emerged as a significant driving force across various industries (Soleymanpoor et al., 2025). The flood of data, coupled with the availability of processing power and storage in digital devices, has generated a renewed interest in artificial intelligence (AI) across various fields in recent years (Sharma et al., 2022). Intense competition among organizations worldwide has also accelerated the need for AI deployment to gain an edge over competitors (Saadisalih et al., 2025). AI is often not perceived by most managers as a core competency that organizations must cultivate to remain competitive in the long run (Hanandeh et al., 2024). One of the key areas of AI application in organizational operations has been B2B marketing (Mikalef et al., 2021). Intelligent solutions are essential for enhancing B2B marketing capabilities in a complex business environment, as B2B operations often involve extensive informational complexity and the need for rapid decision-making. In this regard, due to its ability to process increasing volumes of data and provide rich insights into business partners and key customers, AI has the potential to transform conventional activities (Karamipour et al., 2025). Furthermore, AI applications have been proposed to enable the automation of many manual processes, which can help reduce bottlenecks and increase operational efficiency in B2B operations (Emami et al., 2025). Nevertheless, despite the aforementioned benefits for large organizations, the implementation of AI in B2B marketing for small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) faces different complexities and obstacles. These companies, which are considered the backbone of the economy, unlike large corporations, often struggle with severe marketing budget constraints, a lack of massive datasets for training algorithms, and a shortage of AI specialists (Chatterjee et al., 2021). In the B2B world, where relationships are built on trust and long decision-making cycles, small companies need to know how AI can make their marketing processes intelligent and personalized without damaging human relationships (Zholghadr et al., 2025). Therefore, the primary issue is that despite the inevitable necessity of digital transformation, there is still no methodical model for integrating AI into B2B marketing strategies in small and medium-sized enterprises. There are many unknown aspects regarding how the managers of these companies adopt this technology and its actual impact on redefining their sales and marketing strategies. Hence, this research seeks to answer the following question: What is the role of AI in the transformation of marketing strategies? Theoretical foundations Artificial intelligence refers to a set of technologies that allow machines to simulate functions similar to human intelligence, including learning, reasoning, problem solving, and language comprehension. In fact, artificial intelligence is a system that, by complex algorithms, has the ability to process huge volumes of unstructured data to identify hidden patterns and make predictions or decisions based on them (saadisalih et al., 2025). This ability to analyze patterns distinguishes artificial intelligence from traditional data analysis tools, because artificial intelligence-based systems have the characteristic of “self-correction” and can continuously improve the accuracy of their predictions by receiving new data (seyed javadin et al., 2025). (Soleymanpoor et al., 2025) in a study entitled "Providing a model of effective factors in the socialization of artificial intelligence technologies", the results of the analysis showed that both independent and dependent variables have a direct positive and significant effect. (Rostam zadeh ganji et al., 2025) in a study entitled "Providing a model of developing employee cognitive trust in artificial intelligence", the results show that causal factors include transparency, training and awareness, ethical compliance and defining common roles and goals, contextual factors such as organizational culture and resources; intervening factors such as employee resistance and system complexity, and strategies including employee training and empowerment are known as key tools in improving human-machine interactions. Research Methodology The present study is applicable in terms of purpose, and qualitative in nature with an exploratory-explanatory approach, designed and implemented based on the grounded theory strategy. The main objective of this study is to identify key components and explain the relationships among artificial intelligence technologies, the transformation of B2B marketing strategies, and their outcomes at the level of small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs). The statistical population of the study included marketing managers, sales strategists in the business-to-business sector, AI implementation specialists, and senior managers of small and medium-sized enterprises participated in the digitalization process of their commercial activities. Sampling was conducted by a purposive (judgmental) method to ensure that the participants possessed lived experience and a deep understanding of the challenges and opportunities of AI in the B2B environment. The data collection process continued until the stage of theoretical saturation, which was ultimately achieved through 15 in-depth interviews. Data analysis was carried out in three stages—open, axial, and selective coding—by MAXQDA10 software. Research Findings The research findings indicated that the transformation of B2B marketing strategies is a pivotal phenomenon shaped by causal factors such as the necessity of big data analysis and competitive pressure. This process, within the context of the organization’s digital maturity and through the management of intervening factors such as employee resistance and financial constraints, is realized through strategies like intelligent personalization and predictive analytics. Ultimately, the implementation of this paradigm model leads to prominent strategic outcomes, including the enhancement of competitive performance, reduction of the sales cycle, and improvement of the organizational customer experience. Discussion and Conclusion The research findings indicate that competitive pressure acts as one of the primary drivers steering small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) toward artificial intelligence. In today’s industrial markets, acquiring strategic customers is no longer feasible through traditional methods, and the necessity of analyzing competitive big data has forced organizations to adopt intelligent tools. This finding is consistent with the results of Mikale et al. (2021). Profound transformations in the structure of industrial markets, including supply chain complexity and the urgent need to minimize human error in sales forecasting, act as external drivers. The findings of the current study suggest that due to high volatility in B2B markets, traditional forecasting models have lost their effectiveness. This aligns with the research by Seyedjavadin et al. (2025), which emphasizes the role of business culture in formulating AI-driven strategies. According to the extracted model, value creation through intelligent insights is the defining milestone that distinguishes leading firms. This finding is closely related to the results of Labin et al. (2024), who identified six emerging clusters in smart marketing (including dynamic market strategies), demonstrating that AI shifts the nature of “strategy” from a static state to a dynamic, data-driven one. Data analysis revealed that success in marketing transformation is highly dependent on digital maturity and the culture of innovation adoption within managerial echelons. The quality of customer data and the availability of cloud platforms provide the necessary foundation for executing the model. This outcome aligns with the research of Bagheri et al. (2024), who investigated the level of digitalization in knowledge-based companies. Indeed, without structured data infrastructures and specialized human resources, even the most advanced AI tools cannot bring about strategic transformation. The research findings showed that at the operational level, the resistance of traditional sales staff and the lack of technical expertise constitute the most serious operational challenges. These barriers, identified as intervening factors in the model, indicate that strategic transformation extends beyond technology acquisition and requires a shift in the organization’s human capital. This finding is consistent with the results of Rostamzadeh Ganji et al. (2025) regarding the importance of employees’ cognitive trust; until employees trust the accuracy and functionality of AI, they will resist the implementation of algorithm-based strategies. Furthermore, this is closely related to the study by Soleymanpour et al. (2025) on the necessity of “technology socialization,” meaning that small firms must establish the necessary cultural and educational foundations for AI adoption within the organization prior to model deployment to prevent early-stage project failure. The results demonstrated that factors such as financial constraints, regulatory gaps, and particularly the unique challenges of the Iranian business environment—such as “sanctions and lack of access to international tools”—affect the model’s outcomes as critical and intervening limitations. The findings of the present study indicate that due to weak financial resources, SMEs lack the capability to compete with large organizations in acquiring licensed technologies. This finding matches the results of Ahmad (2025) regarding ethical and infrastructural challenges, as well as the research by Zolghadr et al. (2025), which emphasized the role of export and technological capabilities in electronic industries. The research findings revealed that one of the primary strategies for transformation is the re-engineering of traditional processes and aligning them with the requirements of the digital age. This re-engineering encompasses a shift in managerial attitudes and redesigning decision-making structures from intuitive to data-driven modes. This finding is consistent with the research of Seyedjavadin et al. (2025), which highlights the role of business culture in formulating AI-driven strategies. At the operational level, the findings suggest that firms must move toward intelligent tactics such as strategic personalization at scale and the utilization of predictive analytics in B2B interactions. These tactics allow the organization to focus on opportunities with higher success probabilities by accurately predicting the needs of strategic customers. This outcome is closely related to the research of Emami et al. (2025) regarding the design of an AI-based Customer Relationship Management (CRM) model. It is also aligned with the findings of Saadisalih et al. (2025) regarding innovative models for technology implementation in target markets. Ultimately, the implementation of these strategies leads to the key outcome of enhancing organizational performance and establishing a competitive advantage. The results showed that the synergy between process re-engineering and intelligent tactics not only increases sales force productivity but also places the firm in a superior position relative to competitors by creating value through intelligent insights. This finding is fully consistent with the results of Karampour (2025), which emphasized the impact of AI capabilities on organizational performance in B2B environments.

Original Article (Qualitative) Marketing Management

Presenting a Pattern for Ranking Insurance Companies Based on Brand Equity

Pages 19-35

https://doi.org/10.22034/jnamm.2026.580780.1282

Abolfazl Aghadadi, ALIREZA ROUSTA, Farzad Asayesh

Abstract Abstract The aim of this study is to present a model for ranking insurance companies based on brand equity. In terms of implementation, this research is qualitative and was conducted by the content analysis method. The statistical population of the study consisted of 10 experts, including managers, specialists, and faculty members, selected through purposive sampling. Sampling continued until theoretical saturation of categories was achieved. The data collection instrument was semi‑structured interviews. For data analysis, first, by means of a qualitative approach and the content analysis technique—including open coding, axial coding, and selective coding—the components related to brand equity were extracted. Subsequently, MAXQDA software was applied for data analysis. The findings indicated that 36 components were identified and an initial model was developed. Based on the final conceptual model, the most important factors influencing brand equity in the ranking of insurance companies include service characteristics, customer characteristics, financial performance, profitability, credibility and public trust, innovation and technology, investment and financial assets, symbolic characteristics, and the service environment. Introduction In the contemporary era, many organizations have come to recognize that one of their most valuable assets is the brand of their products and services. Numerous studies have shown that building a strong brand is one of the key factors in achieving competitive advantage and ensuring long-term survival in competitive markets (Santos et al., 2023). A strong brand creates value not only for customers but also for the organization. On one hand, brands serve as effective tools for simplifying the process of product or service selection and purchase, facilitating information processing for customers and thereby increasing perceived value. On the other hand, while product design and production processes can often be easily imitated, the brand image and positioning—formed through years of marketing activities and customer experiences—cannot be easily replicated (Keller, 2017). Therefore, organizations relying on strong brands can implement higher pricing strategies, create more effective commercial leverage, increase their profit margins, and be less vulnerable to competitors (Aaker, 2025). Over the past two decades, the concept of brand equity has attracted considerable attention in marketing literature. Factors such as rapid technological innovations, the globalization of markets, and the increasing power of retailers have all emphasized the importance of understanding and measuring brand equity. Despite the existence of multiple definitions, there is a theoretical consensus that brand equity represents the added value that a product or firm obtains solely through its brand name (Hunt, 2019). Accurately measuring brand value has always been associated with challenges, as marketing decisions are often made in uncertain and dynamic environments, and numerous factors contribute to the formation of brand value. Under such conditions, the application of fuzzy approaches can serve as an effective tool for reducing uncertainty and improving the accuracy of evaluations. The findings of the present study can contribute scientifically by paving the way for future research in the field of insurance company ranking and by enriching the existing literature in this area. From a practical perspective, it can assist insurance companies in identifying performance criteria and aligning their performance accordingly. In the Iranian insurance industry, although all stakeholders—including insurance company managers, policyholders, and regulatory authorities—recognize the importance of branding, there is no standardized, quantitative, and widely accepted model for measuring and ranking the brand equity of insurance companies based on scientific dimensions tailored to the specific conditions of the Iranian market. Evaluations are generally conducted based on traditional financial and operational indicators such as written premiums, loss ratio, and operating profit. Therefore, aiming to propose a model for ranking insurance companies based on brand equity, the present study holds multidimensional importance and necessity, and seeks to answer the following question: What is the appropriate model for ranking insurance companies based on brand equity? Theoretical Framework Brand Equity Brand equity is of critical importance because it enables a brand to achieve greater significance and revenue in competition with rivals. Brand equity is a complex construct that encompasses numerous parameters such as brand image, brand identity, brand awareness, brand loyalty, brand associations, and others. Although this construct is largely subjective and qualitative in nature, it can be represented quantitatively. Brand equity is formed through marketing strategies, sustained efforts over time, and consistency, which collectively lead to customer perceptions and brand knowledge that may be either positive or negative. Positive perceptions result in increased brand equity. Effectively communicating product benefits to customers contributes to brand building. Companies invest substantial amounts in advertising through integrated marketing communication channels to promote their goods and services (Saputra & Margareta, 2020). Derisi et al. (2026) examined the development of a brand reputation model aimed at enhancing brand equity in the pharmaceutical industry. The qualitative findings revealed that five main categories constitute the brand reputation model: causal conditions (proven quality, drug safety monitoring systems, credible scientific data), contextual conditions (institutional collaboration, scientific–economic interaction with policymakers, international standards), intervening conditions (geopolitical factors, multi-level competition, technological developments), strategies (scientific excellence, transparency, crisis management, indigenous innovation), and consequences (sustained trust, market position, scientific credibility, and policy bargaining power). In the quantitative phase, the results indicated high validity of the extracted model. Sabzvari et al. (2025) investigated the identification of brand equity creation components in the Iranian apparel industry. According to the findings, four components—internal brand strength, brand awareness, positive brand image, and perceived value—are the most critical determinants of brand equity creation in Iran’s apparel industry, and the proposed model demonstrated an acceptable level of fit. Research Methodology This study was conducted through a qualitative approach and the content analysis method. The statistical population consisted of 10 experts, including managers, specialists, and faculty members, selected through purposive sampling. The sampling process continued until theoretical saturation of the categories was achieved. The data collection instrument was semi‑structured interviews. Research Findings For data analysis, first, by means of a qualitative approach and the content analysis technique—including open coding, axial coding, and selective coding—the components related to brand equity were extracted. Subsequently, MAXQDA software was employed for data analysis. The findings indicated that 36 components were identified and an initial model was developed. Based on the final conceptual model, the most important factors influencing brand equity in ranking insurance companies include service characteristics, customer characteristics, financial performance, profitability, credibility and public trust, innovation and technology, investment and financial assets, symbolic characteristics, and the service environment. Conclusion The present study was conducted with the aim of developing a model for ranking insurance companies based on brand equity. The findings of this study are consistent with the results of Derisi et al. (2026), Sabzvari et al. (2025), Borjalilou and Emadinasab (2025), Mohammadnezhad and Rezaei Dizgah (2025), Nam et al. (2023), Lurriro and Miranda (2023), Jontonton et al. (2022), Yazdani Kachuei et al. (2022), Mohammad (2022), Balmer and Podnar (2021), and Sarker et al. (2021). Borjalilou and Emadinasab (2025) demonstrated that corporate brand identity has a positive and significant effect on employee-based brand equity dimensions, including brand citizenship behavior, employee satisfaction, word-of-mouth promotion, and intention to continue collaboration. Furthermore, the dimensions of corporate brand identity—namely brand visual identity, brand personality, employee and customer orientation, and sustainable communications—also have a positive and significant impact on employee-based brand equity, although these effects are not strong. Among these dimensions, employee and customer orientation and sustainable communications, which are more closely related to organizational human resource policies, exert stronger effects on employee-based brand equity. In contrast, brand visual identity and brand personality, which reflect broader and more general meanings of brand identity, have comparatively weaker effects on employee-based brand equity. Based on the research findings, it is recommended that companies disclose the results of such evaluations in their annual reports to shareholders in order to enhance accountability and transparency.

Original Article (Qualitative) Other topics related to business management, entrepreneurship, and marketing

Structural Architecture of Entertainment in Modern Advertising: Identifying Core Variables through Word Co‑Occurrence Analysis

Pages 36-60

https://doi.org/10.22034/jnamm.2026.578263.1259

Mohammad Hadi Hedayati Zafarghandi, Maysam Shafiee Roodposhti

Abstract Abstract The aim of the present study is to identify the architecture of the entertainment structure in modern advertising; identifying core variables with word co-occurrence analysis. The present study is descriptive in terms of its purpose and developmental in terms of its application, and it was conducted through the meta-synthesis approach and scientometric techniques (synonymous analysis and co-authorship). This study applies a combined approach including "systematic review" and "word co-occurrence network analysis" to redefine the internal architecture of the entertainment structure. The meta-synthesis method was applied to analyze the findings, and the scientometric approach and VOSviewer software were utilized to combine, cluster, and structurally analyze the extracted concepts. The results showed that by analyzing 211 key vocabulary units extracted from reputable scientific sources, 9 fundamental variables in behavioral and experiential dimensions were identified and explained in the form of a comprehensive classification. While criticizing the ineffectiveness of classical models in explaining the modern complexities of advertising, the findings of this study provide an evidence-based framework for operationalizing the construct. This research not only contributes to the development of consumer behavior theories, but also provides a strategic tool for marketing managers to design and evaluate advertising content. The results of this research provide a solid basis for future empirical research to measure the effectiveness of these dimensions in platform-based environments. Introduction Rapid changes in media, content consumption patterns, and the ways in which audiences encounter commercial messages have highlighted the role of entertainment in advertising effectiveness more than ever before. In an age of message saturation, fast scrolling, short videos, and skippable ads; only those messages are likely to be seen and processed that create an enjoyable, engaging, and meaningful experience (Shafiee et al., 2024; Teixeira, 2014). Recent research suggests that entertaining elements such as humor, narrative, digital aesthetics, creativity, and cognitive stimulation can increase attention, enhance depth of processing, and improve the experience of encountering an ad (Gallo, 2023; Simonetti, 2024; Huang, 2023). This evidence highlights the importance of entertainment as one of the main drivers of the advertising experience in contemporary media environments. Despite this importance, the existing literature suggests that the concept of entertainment remains fragmented, multifaceted, and lacks theoretical coherence. Studies have explained this construct in different formats: some have considered it equivalent to cognitive engagement (Cline, 2007; Makienko, 2014); some have analyzed it in the context of narrative (Green & Brock, 2000; Wang, 2021); and others have limited it to emotional or aesthetic experiences. More recent studies also show that entertainment in digital, algorithmic, and OTT media has a more multifaceted nature and requires redefinition (Yu, 2024; Malik, 2024; Song, 2022). This conceptual heterogeneity highlights the need to review and integrate the literature. Accordingly, the aim of the present study is not to present a predetermined model, but to conduct a systematic review based on scientometric analysis of the last four decades and to identify the core variables of advertising entertainment; variables that can serve as the basis for developing new theoretical frameworks, valid measurement tools, and more accurate modeling in future research. This redefinition not only contributes to the theoretical richness of the literature, but also allows for the alignment of existing models with contemporary media conditions, including digital, algorithmic, interactive, and short-narrative advertising. Therefore, the main question of this research is: how does the architecture of the structure of entertainment in modern advertising; the identification of core variables by word co-occurrence analysis look like? Theoretical Framework Entertainment in Advertising Advertising as an effective tool for raising awareness and introducing companies, goods, services, and even ideas and perspectives has undergone extensive changes over time. In the contemporary world, advertising has become an integral element of the structure of organizations and even cultural and social arenas, such that the continued effective activity of many businesses and social institutions depends largely on the level of success in information and advertising (Sinha, 2021). Advertising is a purposeful activity that introduces and promotes products or services through advertising messages to increase sales and strengthen brand recognition (Smith & Johnson, 2022). Entertainment in advertising has been considered one of the most effective mechanisms for shaping the audience's experience and increasing the effectiveness of the message over the past four decades. However, a systematic review of the literature shows that this construct has been explained over time with different theoretical approaches and there is still no unified and agreed-upon framework for defining and measuring it. Research in this area can be categorized into several main conceptual clusters, each of which sheds light on part of the nature of entertainment, but none of which alone is capable of providing a comprehensive picture of it. Mir Motahari et al. (2025) investigated the evaluation of the role of outdoor advertising on the use of eye movements towards the brand. In this study, causal conditions (advertising content; quality of outdoor advertising and advertising features); main contextual factors (advertising slogan, billboard elements and analysis of customer eye movements); intervening conditions (online advertising, advertising costs, advertising through media and mass communication); pivotal categories (environmental advertising status, development of advertising effectiveness and effective advertising on customer intentions); strategies (attractions of advertising message, evaluation of the environmental advertising selection process) and three categories of competitive advantage, value creation and promotion of strategic marketing decisions are classified as the consequences of environmental advertising based on the use of eye trackers. Danaei (2025) investigated the effect of media (radio) advertising effectiveness on the degree of consumers' tendency to consume domestic goods. The results of this study showed that the effectiveness of media advertising (radio) has a positive and significant effect on consumers' tendency to consume domestic goods. Research Methodology The present study is descriptive in terms of purpose and developmental in terms of application, and was conducted by a meta-synthesis approach and scientometric techniques (synonymous analysis and co-authorship). This study applies a combined approach including "systematic review") and "word co-occurrence network analysis" to redefine the internal architecture of the entertainment construct. Research Findings The meta-synthesis method was employed to analyze the findings, and the scientometric approach and VOSviewer software were employed to combine, cluster, and structurally analyze the extracted concepts. The results showed that by analyzing 211 key lexical units extracted from reliable scientific sources, 9 fundamental variables were identified in behavioral and empirical dimensions and explained in the form of a comprehensive classification. While criticizing the inefficiency of classical models in explaining the modern complexities of advertising, the findings of this study provide an evidence-based framework for operationalizing the construct. This research not only contributes to the development of theories of consumer behavior, but also provides a strategic tool for marketing managers to design and evaluate advertising content. The results of this research provide a solid basis for future empirical research to measure the effectiveness of these dimensions in platform-based environments. Conclusion The present study aimed to identify the core variables of the construct of entertainment in modern advertising by analyzing the co-occurrence of words. The results of this study are consistent with the results of Mir Motahari et al. (2025), Danaei (2025), Mohammadi et al. (2024), Hessani Khabr et al. (2025), Shen & Wang (2024), Bagher Mosavi & Fadai (2023), Ahadi & Ghasemi (2020), and Gordon et al. (2019). Shen & Wang (2024) showed that short video users' personality perception from each dimension has a significant positive effect on shared value creation. Therefore, this study examines the internal correlation and mediating mechanism between short video users' personality perception and purchase intention, establishing mediating and moderating variables. First, shared value creation plays a mediating role between personality perception and purchase intention on short video platforms. Second, two individual-level moderator variables play a moderating role between shared value creation and purchase intention on short-form video platforms: monitoring focus and social presence. Using research variables as a monitoring mechanism helps managers make more informed strategic decisions regarding media selection and message content to maximize the return on advertising spending. Despite methodological rigor, the focus on English-language articles and a specific time period may have overlooked some of the local literature or very emerging research. Also, the findings remain at the theoretical level and need to be empirically validated. Accordingly, it is suggested that researchers design questionnaire items and test their reliability and validity through factor analysis in the next step.

Original Article (Qualitative) business management

Designing a model for improving commercialization in the PVC industry with an emphasis on the role of emerging technologies

Pages 61-83

https://doi.org/10.22034/jnamm.2026.585461.1312

Alireza Salek, Mahmoud Ahmadi Sharif, Musa Rezvani Chaman Zamin, Seyed Mahmoud Hashemi

Abstract Abstract The aim of this study is to design a model for improving commercialization in the PVC industry with an emphasis on the role of emerging technologies. The research method is applicable in terms of its purpose, and exploratory in terms of qualitative approach and data analysis. The statistical population of the study consisted of 15 experts in the PVC industry, including technical and production managers of factories, formulation and R&D specialists, and faculty members in the fields of polymer and technology management, selected by purposive and snowball sampling methods. Semi-structured interviews were applied to collect information. Thematic analysis approach and MAXQDA software were applied to analyze the data. The results showed that the initial codes extracted were categorized into five organizing themes including “Environmental Pressures on Commercialization”, “Technological Capabilities and Capacities”, “Organizational and Management Factors”, “Market and Commercialization Processes”, and “Consequences and Achievements of Commercialization”. Finally, the overarching theme of the research was identified as “Improving Commercialization through Emerging Technologies in the PVC Industry”. The research findings showed that utilizing new technologies, enhancing technological capacities, strengthening knowledge management, developing market-oriented interactions, and improving organizational infrastructure play a decisive role in increasing the effectiveness of the commercialization process in the PVC industry. The results of this research can be used as a practical framework for industrial managers, policymakers, and polymer activists to develop the commercialization of innovative products and technologies. Introduction In recent decades, emerging technologies have played a prominent role in improving organizational performance, increasing competitiveness, and sustainable development as key drivers in the transformation of the structure of various industries. In the meantime, the polymer industry, and especially polyvinyl chloride (PVC), has become one of the most important sub-sectors of the petrochemical industry due to its unique characteristics, including reasonable price, high durability, flexibility in application, and recyclability. The development of new technologies in this area can lead to the production of products with better performance, reduced energy costs, improved environmental properties, and expanded the range of industrial applications (Delogu et al., 2020). Internationally, several models for technology commercialization have been developed that focus on interaction and synergy between key stakeholders such as universities, the private sector, government institutions, and investors. For example, the “triple helix” model emphasizes the synergy of knowledge, policy, and economics to facilitate the process of transforming science into products (Etzkowitz & Leydesdorff, 2022). In these frameworks, knowledge management, market analysis, technology assessment, and business model design are key elements for successful commercialization. However, adapting these models to the economic, cultural, and structural environment of countries such as Iran requires localization and redesign based on local realities (OECD, 2021). New approaches such as open innovation and technology co-creation platforms can be used as components that strengthen the commercialization model. By facilitating participation among stakeholders, these approaches help accelerate the idea-to-market process and can lead to the creation of a sustainable value chain in the PVC industry (Chasbro, 2020). Although the international literature has extensively addressed business models in the polymer materials and chemical industries, a review of recent articles shows that existing research is often either generic and cross-industry, without focusing on the specific characteristics of PVC such as high environmental and regulatory sensitivity, or solely on sectors such as market, technology or regulation, rather than on a comprehensive commercialization model. In particular, the integration of sustainability, circular economy and digitalization dimensions in the design of commercialization models for PVC technologies is less visible in a structured manner. Therefore, the main question that this research seeks to answer is: what does a commercialization improvement model look like in the PVC industry with an emphasis on the role of emerging technologies? Theoretical Framework Commercialization in the PVC Industry In PVC extrusion and granulation lines, monitoring indicators include a set of process, equipment, quality and maintenance variables that comprehensively describe the behavior of the production system. Variables such as temperature, pressure, screw speed, equipment vibration, product weight and color, cutting blade speed, and production rate are among the indicators whose deviation from the optimal range can lead to quality degradation or line shutdown. The thermal sensitivity of PVC makes precise control of temperature and pressure in different areas of the extruder particularly important, as any fluctuations can lead to thermal degradation of the material and an increase in defective products (Pinto et al, 2020). Adomako & Tran (2026) examined Innovation versus Chance; The impact of regulatory challenges on technology commercialization performance and product innovation. Using two-wave, multi-informant survey data from 336 SMEs in Vietnam, the results confirm the mediating role of commercialization potential. Furthermore, while intangible resource advantage strengthens the link between commercialization and innovation, environmental hostility unexpectedly weakens it, indicating that external pressures can overshadow firms’ commercialization efforts. These findings contribute to regulatory science and innovation research by highlighting commercialization potential as a critical mechanism through which institutions influence innovation. The present study provides insights for managers seeking to overcome institutional barriers and for policymakers seeking to create more innovative regulatory environments. Pujotomo et al. (2025) examined a scenario of accelerating technology commercialization in a research university, applying a systems dynamics approach. The results show that TTO participation can reduce delays by directly matching university inventions with early adopters. Furthermore, given that TTOs coordinate initial grants, competitions, and external support; the results also increase funding prospects. Meanwhile, additional funding for inventors can further influence the speed of development, emphasizing the importance of team performance and resource availability. Overall, team dynamics, including expertise and time allocation, are crucial for rapid progress towards TRL levels. Active participation of end-users in design and testing also accelerates improvements. Based on these insights, we provide a practical scenario guide for technology transfer office managers to address budget shortfalls, optimize resources, and shorten commercialization timelines. Research Methodology The research method is applicable in terms of its purpose, and exploratory in terms of qualitative approach and data analysis. The statistical population of the study consisted of 15 experts in the PVC industry, including technical and production managers of factories, formulation and R&D specialists, and faculty members in the fields of polymer and technology management, selected by purposive and snowball sampling methods. Semi-structured interviews were applied to collect data. Research Findings Thematic analysis approach and MAXQDA software were utilized to analyze the data. The results showed that the initial codes extracted were categorized into five organizing themes including “Environmental Pressures on Commercialization”, “Technological Capabilities and Capacities”, “Organizational and Management Factors”, “Market and Commercialization Processes”, and “Consequences and Achievements of Commercialization”. Finally, the overarching theme of the research was identified as “Improving Commercialization through Emerging Technologies in the PVC Industry”. The research findings showed that utilizing new technologies, enhancing technological capacities, strengthening knowledge management, developing market-oriented interactions, and improving organizational infrastructure play a decisive role in increasing the effectiveness of the commercialization process in the PVC industry. The results of this research can be used as a practical framework for industrial managers, policymakers, and polymer activists to develop the commercialization of innovative products and technologies. Conclusion The present study was conducted with the aim of designing a model for improving commercialization in the PVC industry with an emphasis on the role of emerging technologies. The results of this study are consistent with those of Adomako & Tran (2026), Pujotomo et al. (2025), Sato et al. (2025), Banoo Farhang & Ansari (2025), and Momiyond et al. (2024). Pujotomo et al. (2025) showed that TTO participation can reduce delays by directly matching university inventions with early adopters. Furthermore, given that TTOs coordinate initial grants, competitions, and external sponsorships, the results also increase funding prospects. Meanwhile, additional funding for inventors can further impact development speed, emphasizing the importance of team performance and resource availability. Overall, team dynamics—including expertise and time allocation—are critical for rapid progress toward TRL levels. Active participation of end users in design and testing also accelerates improvements. Based on the research results, the following suggestion was made: PVC industry managers should create a structured “environmental monitoring” system to continuously collect, analyze, and link changes in the market, competitors, standard requirements, and environmental policies to technological decisions. This system should be able to provide early warnings and prepare the organization to face external threats. Such an approach prevents the organization from being caught in the middle of sudden changes and makes technological decisions more rational and forward-looking.

Original Article (Mixed) Marketing Management

Identification and Prioritization of the Dimensions and Components of Digital Marketing Adoption in Knowledge-Based Companies

Pages 84-108

https://doi.org/10.22034/jnamm.2026.564355.1220

elaheh soltani, saeed massoodipoor

Abstract Abstract The aim of the present study is to identify and prioritize the challenges of implementing digital marketing in knowledge-based companies located in Qom and Markazi provinces. The research follows a mixed-methods approach, utilizing both qualitative and quantitative techniques. Qualitative data were collected through a literature review and interviews with fourteen managers of knowledge-based companies, selected via snowball sampling until the stage of theoretical saturation. These data were analyzed by the thematic analysis method to identify and categorize the issues. For qualitative data organization, coding, and analysis, MAXQDA 2020 software was employed. Initially, 42 issues were identified and classified into six general categories: cognitive and behavioral issues of managers, financial and funding issues, content-related issues, human resource issues, marketing-oriented issues, and issues related to changes in social platforms and networks. In the second stage, the issues were screened by the Fuzzy Delphi technique in Excel. The screening resulted in 22 final factors, which were then prioritized by the MARCOS technique. The prioritization results indicate that “weakness in retaining expert and specialized human resources” and “lack of marketing research tailored to the digital environment” held the highest priority. Introduction The market is a dynamic, living, and evolving phenomenon (Azizi et al., 2020, p. 4). As the science of responding to human needs within a turbulent market environment, this academic discipline must maintain flexibility and alignment with environmental changes to address corporate requirements. One of the most significant transformations is the remarkable progress and expansion of cyberspace. Given the substantial growth of information and communications technology, which has influenced all aspects of social life and induced extensive changes in various work methods, it can be stated that digital communication tools have encompassed nearly all facets of modern human life (Iran Aghideh, 2021, p. 121; Farzinmehr et al., 2025, p. 102). The widespread use of the Internet and digital tools presents a unique commercial opportunity for managers. The integration of social life with the digital sphere has led to the emergence of a new concept termed digital marketing (Iran Aghideh, 2021, p. 121). As a branch of marketing management and advertising, digital marketing encompasses all tools and activities related to the supply and promotion of products across digital platforms (Gholipour et al., 2016, p. 8; Mohseni et al., 2023, p. 229). This form of marketing refers to the utilization of the Internet and digital technologies such as computers, websites, mobile devices, applications, and email (Ayush et al., 2020, p. 225). Digital marketing, as a new paradigm, has revolutionized the marketing system and marketing knowledge. Given that it is conducted within the context of the Internet and through its associated techniques, it can be considered the most effective way to introduce products and improve the performance of knowledge-based companies. Consequently, the introduction and marketing of products via digital marketing are decoupled from their place of production; customers can be found from any point in Iran or even the world, and they, in turn, can establish connections with various manufacturers (Shirdel et al., 2022, p. 3). On the other hand, knowledge-based businesses are on the rise and are considered vital to the economy; the knowledge-based economy accounts for a large share of the economy in many developed countries (Hayes, 2021). Therefore, knowledge-based companies can be viewed as the core and driving force of the knowledge-based economy. These companies, which often seek to generate wealth through high technologies, are critical drivers of growth. These firms, like any other, require marketing functions, and specifically, the position of digital marketing is vital and essential in advancing their objectives. Digital marketing can bring numerous benefits to knowledge-based companies that produce and provide high-value-added goods and services based on knowledge and technology (Center for the Growth of Knowledge-Based Companies and Institutions, 2024). Thus, the implementation of digital marketing in knowledge-based companies can significantly contribute to their progress. However, the use of digital marketing in these companies faces challenges and problems that have not been adequately addressed in previous research. Given the necessity of market development and increasing sales for knowledge-based companies, it is imperative to conduct precise and effective research to achieve these goals; identifying these challenges will pave the way for their resolution. Therefore, the present study seeks to address the issue of identifying the obstacles and problems hindering the use and implementation of digital marketing in knowledge-based companies. The research question is: What are the challenges and issues of implementing digital marketing in knowledge-based companies, and which of these hold higher priority? Theoretical Framework Digital Marketing Since the emergence of buying and selling in human relations, the concept of marketing has existed (Mohseni et al., 2023, p. 227). Having transitioned through eras such as hunting, agriculture, and the first to third industrial revolutions, we are now witnessing the Fourth Industrial Revolution. This revolution is essentially considered a revolution in communications, linked to internet technologies that have transformed the world; thus, organizational agility in responding appropriately to changes can be regarded as the key to their success (Petrosian, 2023). Some believe that the emergence of digital marketing coincided with the advent of radio. In 1990, only a few individuals had access to the internet, a number that gradually increased until there were approximately 18 million internet users by 1995. In 1999, the Salesforce website introduced the first customer management system for storing user information, tracking their behavior on the site, and monitoring campaigns; this software is recognized as the core foundation for the formation of digital marketing (Mohseni et al., 2023, p. 228). In simple terms, digital marketing can be defined as the execution of marketing plans and strategies through the internet and other related digital platforms. In fact, it can be defined as a marketing approach that primarily relies on the internet to communicate with target audiences through various digital media channels and platforms. In digital marketing, marketers utilize the internet, mobile devices, email, social media, search engines, video streaming platforms, and other channels to reach customers. At the same time, some marketing experts argue that digital marketing should be viewed as an entirely different and new endeavor that requires novel and distinct methods for approaching, communicating with, and understanding customers. Since digital technology lies at the heart of all companies, digital marketing serves as an essential tool for brands and marketers ydigital marketing provides organizations with the opportunity and space to strive for success in utilizing local and domestic markets (Nejati, 2022, p. 25). Research Methodology The present study adopts an inductive approach and falls within the category of exploratory and applicable research. Its strategy is survey-based, and in terms of implementation, it was conducted by a mixed-methods design. Data collection instruments included documents and semi-structured interviews in the qualitative phase, and a questionnaire in the quantitative phase. The theoretical population consisted of knowledge-based companies located in the Science and Technology Parks of Qom and Arak. Fifteen companies were selected as the sample for interviews, and data collection continued until theoretical saturation was achieved. Research Findings The thematic analysis method and MAXQDA 2020 software were employed for data analysis. The findings revealed 150 initial codes which, through consolidation, resulted in 42 basic themes. these were categorized into six organizing themes: cognitive and behavioral issues of managers, financial and funding issues, content-related issues, human resource issues, marketing-oriented issues, and changes in social platforms and networks. In the second step, due to the high number of basic themes, the Fuzzy Delphi method was applied to screen the issues. A questionnaire containing 42 issues was sent to 10 experts; ultimately, 22 issues with a defuzzified value greater than 0.5 were selected as the final challenges. For the final ranking, the MARCOS method was utilized. Conclusion The present study aimed to identify and prioritize the dimensions and components of implementing digital marketing in knowledge-based companies. The results of this study are consistent with the findings of previous studies of Shiri & Moradnejadi (2024); Gholipour et al. (2016); Papi et al. (2022); and Farast (2020). Based on the prioritization results, factors such as weakness in retaining expert and specialized human resources, lack of marketing research aligned with the digital environment, the lack of up-to-date digital marketing education in universities in line with the latest scientific and technological developments, and insufficient attention to the long-term outcomes of digital marketing were identified as the most significant issues. As noted by Shiri and Moradnejadi (2024), efficient human resources equipped with sufficient knowledge, who can address societal needs—including those of knowledge-based companies—through their expertise and contribute to national development, are of great importance. As long as there is no adequate and accurate understanding of the market and competitors, the application of marketing knowledge will face challenges. Excessive focus on innovation and product uniqueness (without attention to the needs of online customers), along with insufficient awareness of marketing and digital marketing and the failure to conduct marketing research appropriate to the digital environment, will collectively lead to difficult and costly outcomes for businesses. Based on the research findings, the following practical recommendations are proposed: Designing a comprehensive system for the retention and development of digital human capital Institutionalizing data-driven digital marketing research Redesigning the university education system with a skills-oriented approach Enhancing managers’ strategic literacy regarding digital marketing Reforming organizational structures and consolidating the position of digital marketing Diversifying digital channels and managing platform-related risks Improving infrastructures related to trust, security, and digital financial transparency

Original Article (Quantified) Marketing Management

Augmented Reality Features and Customer Behavior: The Role of Customer Engagement

Pages 109-135

https://doi.org/10.22034/jnamm.2026.582165.1296

Mohammad Mahmoudi Maymand, Hossein Tebyaniyan, Saeed Arezoomand

Abstract Abstract The aim of this study is to investigate the effect of augmented reality features on customer behavior by considering the role of mediating customer interaction. This study is applicable in terms of its purpose, and descriptive-survey in terms of its data collection method. The statistical population of this study is an unlimited number of all online customers of Panberiz Company in Tehran. According to the Krejci Morgan table, the number of statistical samples in the unlimited population was 384 people, selected through simple random sampling. The main tool for collecting information is a questionnaire. In the data analysis section, descriptive and inferential statistics were employed to test the hypotheses, and the analyses were performed with SmartPLS 3 and SPSS 26 software. The research findings showed that augmented reality features can affect customer behavior and this effect is strengthened by increasing customer interaction. In other words, the more desirable the quality and features of augmented reality, the higher the level of customer engagement and, as a result, the more positive their behavior towards the product or service will be. Finally, the research results emphasize that the use of augmented reality can be an effective tool for attracting, engaging, and guiding customer behavior, and the targeted use of this technology can lead to improved customer experience and enhanced desired behavioral outcomes. Introduction Augmented reality is an innovative technology that overlays digital content on the physical world to enhance users’ understanding and interaction with their environment. The integration of virtual elements with the real-world environment creates immersive experiences that enrich consumer interaction with the product and service providers (Mubdir et al., 2025). In retail, augmented reality creates opportunities for seamless interaction through virtual trials and product visualization, and enhances the shopping experience through personalization and immersion. Augmented reality capabilities are being extended by mobile devices, such as smartphones and tablets, enabling users to interact with products or service providers in a virtual environment. Thus, augmented reality features are highlighted to increase customer engagement, facilitate decision-making, and reinforce positive customer behavior (Doroudi & Babaei, 2025). More engaged customers can experience long-term relationships with brands and businesses, and recommend products and services to other customers, bringing the greatest return to the company at the lowest cost. Despite the growing interest in augmented reality marketing, there are still gaps in understanding its impact on customer behavior. Existing studies have focused on technical and entertainment applications or the role of augmented reality in education, such as enhancing fashion design skills and advancing virtual design practices. However, limited research examines the broader impact of augmented reality on key dimensions such as customer behavior, especially purchase decisions, customer engagement, or brand loyalty (Sarkis et al., 2025). Panbereez Company, as a company active in the cosmetics and health care field and a wide range of customers, can provide customers with more information that is more in line with their interests, desires, and needs, and that better matches reality by using augmented reality technology. Accordingly, considering what was stated, the question is: What is the impact of augmented reality features on customer behavior? What is the role of customer interaction in this? Theoretical Framework Augmented Reality Features Augmented reality features are defined as features such as system quality, perceived information, and consistency with reality in the use of augmented reality technology, which play a pivotal role in guiding hedonic and utilitarian experiences (Barta et al., 2025). Perceived Information Perceived information refers to the extent to which augmented reality applications provide customers with valuable, relevant, and reliable product information (Du et al., 2024). System Quality System quality refers to the technical performance and reliability of the application, including responsiveness, ease of use, and overall usability (Treinen & Kolla, 2024). Customer Engagement Customer engagement behaviors are “the positive cognitive, affective, and behavioral activity of a customer associated with a brand during or in connection with key consumer/brand interactions” (Winell et al., 2023). Customer Behavior Customer behavior refers to the study of how people make decisions about purchasing, using, and disposing of goods and services. It includes the actions, motivations, and influences that shape consumers’ purchasing decisions. Understanding customer behavior is crucial for businesses to tailor their marketing efforts and product offerings to customer needs and preferences (Kaur et al., 2024). Adinda et al. (2025) investigated the effect of social media marketing on purchase intention by mediating customer engagement. The results of the study show that all the tested factors do not have a significant effect on consumer engagement. Monitoring does not affect customer engagement, while information sharing, social interaction, and attractiveness do. In addition, customer engagement significantly affects purchase intention. Indirectly, information sharing, social interaction, and attractiveness have a positive effect on purchase intention through consumer engagement, while monitoring does not. Asante et al. (2025) investigated the use of online multi-channel commerce to increase customer engagement in the era of digital transformation. The results showed that the use of online multi-channel commerce is effective in increasing customer engagement in the era of digital transformation. Research Methodology This research is applicable in terms of purpose, and descriptive-survey in terms of data collection method. The statistical population of this study is all online customers of Panbereez Company in Tehran in unlimited numbers. According to the Krejci Morgan table, the number of statistical samples in the unlimited population was 384 people, selected by simple random sampling. The main tool for collecting information is a questionnaire. Research findings In the data analysis section, descriptive and inferential statistics were used to test the hypotheses, and the analyses were performed with SmartPLS 3 and SPSS 26 software. The research findings showed that augmented reality features can affect customer behavior and this effect is strengthened by increasing customer interaction. In other words, the more desirable the quality and features of augmented reality, the higher the level of customer interaction and, as a result, their positive behaviors towards the product or service also increase. Finally, the research results emphasize that the use of augmented reality can be an effective tool for attracting, engaging, and guiding customer behavior, and the targeted use of this technology can lead to improved customer experience and enhanced desired behavioral outcomes. Conclusion The present study aimed to investigate the impact of augmented reality features on customer behavior by considering the role of mediating customer interaction. The results of this study are consistent with the results of Adinda et al. (2025), Asante et al. (2025), Anwar et al. (2025), Dağ et al. (2025), Xiao & Chen (2025) Sarkis et al. (2025) Masfer & Helmi (2025) Mubdir et al. (2025), Naveen et al. (2025), Taneja & Dutta (2024), Rajendran & Usha (2024), Seidi et al. (2024), Doroudi & Babaei (2025), Zarin Negar et al. (2025), and Por Hoseini & Farahbakht Fomani (2024). Sarkis et al. (2025) showed that augmented reality positively influences purchase decisions, significantly increases customer engagement, and strengthens brand loyalty, highlighting its transformative potential in shaping consumer behavior in the fashion industry. It also increases understanding of how augmented reality technologies can be used to enhance purchase decisions, foster deeper customer engagement, and create stronger brand loyalty, thereby influencing long-term customer relationships with the brand. Based on the research findings, it is suggested that companies improve the quality of augmented reality content delivery by reducing latency, optimizing device and software performance, and creating accurate and natural overlays with the real environment to improve customer behavior. Also, by means of solutions such as focusing on problem solving, accepting and compensating for errors, following up on requests, providing alternatives, using customer relationship management systems, training employees, and better designing the customer experience can help strengthen customer trust, satisfaction, and positive behavior.

Original Article (Mixed) Human resource management in business management

Presenting a Model for the Career and Organizational Advancement of Middle Managers with a Meritocracy Strategy Approach

Pages 136-162

https://doi.org/10.22034/jnamm.2026.582375.1294

Ali Raeis Poor, Pejman Azizi

Abstract Abstract The aim of this study is to present a career and organizational promotion model for middle managers with a meritocracy strategies approach. The research method is applicable in terms of purpose, and of descriptive-exploratory research type. The statistical population of the study includes 12 experts and specialists of Bushehr Petrochemical Company, and the sampling method is purposive. Based on the summary of previous studies and the data obtained from the implementation of the Delphi technique among Bushehr Petrochemical experts, four criteria of meritocracy strategy were identified for career and organizational promotion, meritocracy thinking, organization qualification, and talent management; and by a hierarchical approach, a hierarchy tree was first formed through this method, and then the criteria were ranked by Expert Choice software. The results of this study showed that meritocracy in managers and employees in Bushehr Petrochemical is as follows: meritocracy strategy for career and organizational promotion has a value of 0.362, meritocracy thinking for career and organizational promotion has a value of 0.384, organization qualification has a value of 0.152, and finally talent management has a value of 0.102, and the compatibility rate of 0.004 is also in the acceptable range. These results can transform managers' decisions and cause changes in their attitudes. Introduction Today, given the extremely intense and complex competition, unstable environment, lightning-fast technological advances, the increasing development of information and communications, and... almost no organization can survive without knowledge-based components, which are specialized and experienced managers and employees. The era of information technology and the digital revolution has also doubled the need to pay attention to the value of these precious elements in the life cycle of companies and organizations, and perhaps it can be safely claimed that the progress and excellence of any organization is due to the unique abilities and competencies of its human resources. An organization is a social environment whose cultures and values ​​provide space for the creativity and ingenuity of its employees. Without creating this creative environment, the hope for the growth and flourishing of elites and the emergence of their talents will be an illusion (Rastgar, 2024). On the other hand, the competence of managers in an organization causes the emergence of organizational competence. Therefore, the competence relationship between the individual and the organization is a two-way relationship, which, due to the major benefit from the organization, must naturally grow from the whole to the part, that is, from the organization to the individual. In simpler terms, organizations need to create a suitable space for the activities of competent individuals and the emergence of their competencies (Hajili, 2022). One of the main solutions to get rid of the inefficiency of Iranian organizations is to value competent managers and make appropriate use of their competencies by appointing them to appropriate jobs. However, to establish this system, there is a need to make fundamental changes in the values ​​and culture of organizations, but the role of the government in promoting this thinking correctly and in a principled manner is undeniable (Vahidi Rad et al. 2026). To develop and promote this thinking, it is also necessary to be well acquainted with its obstacles and try to overcome them. On the other hand, the need to establish this system in organizations must become a widespread belief and senior organizational managers must accept it as the only model for saving their troubled organizations. In addition, familiarity with the requirements for implementing this system provides them with more operational solutions and helps them in the correct and comprehensive implementation of this thinking in organizations (Daniyali Deh Hoz et al. 2018). In meritocracy, the latent talents of individuals are usually identified and then cultivated through the creation of a talent base and made available to the organization's goals. Meritocracy begins with the production of competence in employees and managers, then evolves in the context of opportunity creation. In meritocracy, criteria such as commitment, expertise, skill, ability, experience, and compassion are the criteria for selecting and promoting individuals in the organization. The degree of excellence, popularity, attachment, and the use of components in planning, decision-making, and their implementation are in line with the achievement of the organization's goals (Wade & Obwegeser, 2019). When a company helps employees in career promotion, employees are less willing to leave the company. Career promotion can increase employee morale, also increase productivity, and on the other hand help the company become more efficient (Rastiani, 2024). Considering the above, it can be said that the main purpose of conducting the research is to answer the main question: what is the career and organizational promotion pattern of middle managers with the approach of meritocracy strategies? Theoretical Framework Meritocracy Meritocracy is a social system in which the highest power and social status are entrusted to those with the most ability. Meritocracy is a social system in which progress in society is based on individual abilities and competencies, not derived from family wealth or social background (Nasiri & Jafari, 2026). Vahidi Rad et al. (2026) studied the design and presentation of a sustainable human resource management model with a meritocracy promotion approach in seven education districts of Mashhad. The findings in the sustainable human resource management model with a meritocracy promotion approach include 5 dimensions and 24 components, which include merit-based recruitment, sustainable human resource competency development-based improvement, human resource retention with a merit-based approach, sustainable and merit-based human resource performance evaluation, and a performance-based payment system. In the quantitative section, the results showed that the aforementioned model has the necessary validity. According to the results of the research, managers of the seven education districts of Mashhad can promote meritocracy in the organization by developing and strengthening sustainable human resource management. Nasiri & Jafari (2026) studied the identification of the underlying factors and challenges in irresponsible appointments and away from meritocracy in education. The results of data analysis led to the identification of 47 basic themes and 7 organizing themes in the context of the underlying factors in irresponsible appointments and away from meritocracy in education, which were classified into 4 comprehensive themes: management in the shadow of politics; organizational affiliation bottlenecks; conflict between economy and educational strategy; and fundamental structural faults. Also, 105 basic themes and 9 organizing themes were identified in the context of the challenges in irresponsible appointments and away from meritocracy in education, which were classified into 4 comprehensive themes: managerial and organizational crises in the education system; social and cultural crisis in education; inequality crisis in education; and qualitative crisis in education were classified. Considering the identification of the underlying factors and challenges in irresponsible and meritocratic appointments in education in this research, implementing the solutions presented in it can facilitate and bring about the realization of the appointment of competent people in education. Research Methodology Regarding its purpose, the research method is applicable based on its objective, and a descriptive-exploratory research type. The statistical population of the research includes 12 experts and specialists of Bushehr Petrochemical Company, and the sampling method is purposive. Research findings Based on the summary of previous studies and the data obtained from the implementation of the Delphi technique among experts in Bushehr Petrochemical, four criteria of meritocracy strategy for career and organizational promotion, meritocracy thinking, organization competency, and talent management were identified. Through a hierarchical approach, a hierarchy tree was first formed by this method, and then the criteria were ranked by Expert Choice software. The results of this study showed that meritocracy in managers and employees in Bushehr Petrochemical is as follows: meritocracy strategy for career and organizational promotion has a value of 0.362, meritocracy thinking for career and organizational promotion has a value of 0.384, organization competency has a value of 0.152, and finally talent management has a value of 0.102. The compatibility rate of 0.004 is also within the acceptable range. These results can transform managers' decisions and cause changes in their attitudes. Conclusion The present study aimed to present a career and organizational promotion model for middle managers with a meritocracy strategies approach. The results of this study are consistent with the results of Baffour Gyau et al. (2024), Wang et al. (2023), Eskandarany (2024), Alotaibi (2024), Byambaa et al. (2025), Svoboda (2024), Lin et al. (2024), McKinsey (2020), Abdulsalam & Tajudeen (2024), Deloitte (2024), and Khan et al. (2024). The results of Baffour Gyau et al, (2024) study on the dynamic relationship between AI technology innovation in banking and finance and financial performance of banks in 20 countries show that AI technology innovation in banking and finance positively affects the return on assets of banks and highlights its role in increasing financial performance. The interaction term between AI innovation and economic growth emphasizes their joint positive effect on financial performance. Mediation analysis highlights the role of information and communication technology development in transforming AI innovation into improved financial results. According to the results of the study, the following suggestions were made: Training comprehensive AI literacy to bank employees: the findings showed that the bank should shift its focus from training skills in simple tools to training comprehensive AI literacy and enable its workforce to transform from passive users to active participants in the AI ​​ecosystem.

Original Article (Qualitative) Human resource management

Developing a Human Resource Development Scenarios Using a Strategic Foresight Approach

Pages 163-187

https://doi.org/10.22034/jnamm.2026.583248.1305

Mehdi Avini, Shamsosadat Zahedi, Mohammad Montazeri

Abstract Abstract The aim of this research is to formulate a human resources development scenario for the traffic police with a foresight approach. This research was applicable-developmental in terms of purpose, and qualitative in terms of research method. The statistical population of the research includes 14 traffic police managers. Individuals were selected by a purposeful method based on at least 10 years of management experience and complete familiarity with this field. The MICMAC and Wizard Scenario methods were utilized to analyze the findings. The results showed that 11 drivers of new traffic police technologies, behavioral and social changes in drivers, traffic police economic policies, revision of traffic police laws, global convergence in traffic management, demographic and aging challenges, development of traffic culture, public demands on traffic police, management of traffic police emergencies, road traffic safety, and sustainable development of traffic management are effective in developing a human resources development scenario for the traffic police. Also, based on the results of Scenario Wizard, a total of eighty-five scenarios are presented to the traffic police. However, two scenarios of progress and development and awareness raising have been introduced as the most important and likely paths to achieving the goals, which have higher priority than others. Introduction Globalization and the rapid growth of information and communication technology have brought a fundamental change to the human resource management process, and the role and function of human resources have been marginalized by the strong presence of information and communication technology, and it is even feared that some day human resource management will be realized without the role of humans in all organizational areas and dimensions (Naji & Alirezaei, 2025). Human resources, as the most valuable organizational resource, are the main axis of the organization's approaches and activities and play a fundamental role in achieving the organization's goals and ideals (Babaei Meybodi & Alirezaei, 2020). Like many organizations, the police organization depends on efficient and capable human resources. The nature of police work and being in stressful situations requires efficient human resources (Parsay et al. 2020). Training and development are critical to the success of an organizational HRM strategy, yet there is abundant evidence that shows some organizations fail to achieve desired business outcomes through training interventions (Dixit & Sinha, 2020). In general, several studies have argued that training and development are critical to the success of an organizational HRM strategy, yet there is abundant evidence that shows some organizations fail to achieve desired business outcomes through training interventions. According to estimates from the American Association for Training and Development, organizations in the United States spend more than $126 billion on employee training and development each year. This amount has increased to $135 billion by 2010 (Dixit & Sinha, 2020). Employing a foresight approach and developing plausible scenarios can help identify trends, key uncertainties, and future skill needs and provide a basis for designing human resource development strategies in traffic police. Despite the importance of this issue, limited studies in the research literature have specifically addressed the scenario development of human resources in the traffic police with a foresight approach; therefore, this study seeks to identify possible scenarios for the development of human resources in the traffic police by utilizing foresight methods and provide a framework for strategic planning in this area. Considering what has been said, this study seeks to answer the question: how is the formulation of a scenario for the development of human resources in the traffic police with a foresight approach? Theoretical framework Human resource development Human resource development is a set of programs, activities, components and systems designed and implemented to improve performance. Traditionally, improving the performance of the organization is facilitated through three broad areas including training and development, evaluation, program and development in the organization. It can be decisively stated that these fields are not just concepts of human resource development and only part of the human resource development literature (Abili et al. 2020). Abdulkazem Helu Al Rakabi et al. (2025) conducted a research with the aim of providing a model for improving human resource management with an emphasis on technology-oriented education in the era of digital transformation. The research results showed that there is a 17-factor model with 88 indicators for improving human resource management in the age of digital transformation. This model includes seven causal factors, six background factors, two intervening factors and two strategies. The findings showed that there are significant relationships between all the factors of the model and its two strategies. Also, the presented model has a strong overall fit. This research can be useful for managers and policymakers by taking advantage of technology-based training to improve human resource management in their organizations in the era of digital transformation. Rajabi Farjad et al. (2025) conducted a research with the aim of identifying and prioritizing the challenges of human resource management in the digital age. The research is applicable in terms of purpose, and descriptive in terms of method. The research method in the study is Delphi in the qualitative part and descriptive research in the quantitative part. Statistical population of the research consists of specialists in human resources management and information technology, Tehran's Asan-Pardakht company. The sample size in both sections (Delphi and TOPSIS Fuzzy), consists of 10 experts. The main tool for collecting information was a questionnaire based on theoretical foundations and conducting three rounds of the Delphi method, the validity of which was based on the technique of long-term engagement with long-term contact with the participants. Then, weighting was carried out by TOPSIS algorithm according to the opinions of experts. The findings of the research showed that the sub-indices of the need for a revolutionary change in society and organization, digital investment, promotion of value creation, information sharing and facilitating organizational changes were ranked first in the research. In addition, the sub-indices of understanding the need to change behavior, communication and interaction with the customer, human resources as a business partner, promoting innovation, the ability to work with tools in the digital field and designing organizational change processes are the factors that have the least impact on the challenges of human resource management in the digital era. Research methodology This research was applicable-developmental in terms of purpose, and qualitative in terms of research method. The statistical population of the research includes 14 traffic police managers. Individuals were selected by a purposeful method based on at least 10 years of management experience and complete familiarity with this field. Research findings MICMAC and Wizard Scenario methods were applied for the analysis. The results showed that 11 drivers of new traffic police technologies, behavioral and social changes of drivers, economic policies of traffic police, revision of traffic police laws, global convergence in traffic management, population and aging challenges, development of traffic culture, public demands from traffic police, management of emergency situations of traffic police, road traffic safety, sustainable evolution of traffic management are effective in formulating the development scenario of traffic police human resources. Also, based on the results of scenario wizard, a total of eighty-five scenarios are facing the traffic police. However, the two scenarios of progress and development and raising awareness have been introduced as the most important and most likely paths for achieving the goals, which have a higher priority than others. Conclusion The present study was conducted with the aim of formulating the human resources development scenario of the traffic police with a foresight approach.. The results of this research are somewhat in agreement with the findings of Abdulkazem Helu Al Rakabi et al. (2025), Rajabi Farjad et al. (2025), Lotfollahi Haqi et al. (2025), Reza Alizadeh et al. (2025), Mehraban et al. (2025), Shariati et al. (2025), Gheiravani et al. (2023), Banmairuroy et al. (2022), Nnadi et al. (2021), Vahabi et al. (2019), Taheri Damaneh et al. (2014), Vahabi et al. (2019), and Staller et al. (2023). Mehraban et al. (2025) showed that in order to maximize the effectiveness and efficiency of the organization's people, while familiarizing them with the environment and justifying them based on their needs, managers and officials should develop appropriate training courses for human resources in education and training. In the end, based on the findings of the research, it is suggested that artificial intelligence be used to analyze historical data (accidents, weather, traffic) in order to identify accident-prone points and deploy agents proactively. Also, drones equipped with thermal cameras should be used to cover blind areas and monitor violations on inaccessible roads.

Original Article (Qualitative) Strategic Management

Determining the relationships and ranking of desirable risk control factors in the medical laboratory supply chain using an interpretive structural approach

Pages 188-216

https://doi.org/10.22034/jnamm.2026.569528.1241

Masoumeh Pashapour, Mehdi Zakipour, Reza Mohamadi, Amir Mohammadzadeh

Abstract Abstract The aim of this study is to determine the relationships and hierarchical levels of optimal risk control factors in the medical laboratory supply chain using an Interpretive Structural Modeling (ISM) approach. In terms of implementation, this research adopts a mixed-methods design (qualitative–quantitative); and in terms of purpose, it is an exploratory study conducted through a descriptive–survey method. The statistical population of the study consisted of 15 senior managers and experts working in medical laboratories across the supply chain, selected by the snowball sampling method. Data were collected through semi-structured interviews. For data analysis, the Fuzzy Delphi method, Interpretive Structural Modeling (ISM), and MICMAC software were employed. The results of the interpretive structural analysis using the exploratory model indicated that the proposed model consists of four main factors and thirteen sub-factors identified across four levels. The fourth level involves supply chain risk identification, including the dimensions of financial and legal risks, quality risks, and supplier and logistics risks. The third level includes failure mode and effects analysis, encompassing the identification of weaknesses, analysis of failure effects, and risk prioritization. The second level involves risk response and management strategies, including supplier diversification, emergency planning, and quality control supported by information technology. Finally, the factors and dimensions identified in the previous three levels lead, at the first level, to achieving optimal risk control, which includes risk and failure reduction, increased supply chain efficiency, continuous improvement, and performance monitoring. Introduction The extensive use of medical and laboratory technologies requires a significant number of resources for the procurement of equipment and materials; an issue that must be given considerable attention in these organizations. It is evident that if the procurement of equipment and materials is carried out without a precise and structured mechanism, the quality of purchases will not align with the actual needs of healthcare centers. Therefore, the procurement process in medical centers is of great importance and must be continuously monitored. Risk assessment is a systematic process for measuring quantitative and qualitative hazards associated with materials, processes, activities, personnel, equipment, and the environment (Rahmanifar, 2014). Utilizing the findings of this research on the supplier side can lead to the development of structures that ensure timely procurement and provide an understanding of risks and potential failure points in the laboratory supply process. As a result, suppliers can devise various methods to meet laboratory needs. Considering that the researcher is also active in the laboratory supply sector, if the findings are validated, they can be presented to the laboratory community through multiple sessions, thus contributing to the dissemination and expansion of the research results. Given that multiple methods and individuals are involved in the procurement of laboratory necessities, this analytical approach can also be applied in this study, representing one of its innovative aspects. Failure Mode and Effects Analysis (FMEA) is one of the most widely used tools for enhancing the reliability and safety of products or processes (Radpour & Karbasian, 2011). This tool is particularly used in the design and development of new products (Fattahi, 2009). Various techniques exist for risk identification, and no single method serves as the best approach; instead, an appropriate combination of techniques should be utilized. Moreover, evaluating risks solely based on their probability of occurrence and severity of impact is insufficient, as these two criteria do not fully capture all influential aspects of risk. FMEA is an analytical technique that combines technology and expertise to prevent the procurement of substandard products and protect the reputation of the organization (Radpour & Karbasian, 2011). Therefore, aligned with this objective, the main research question of the present study is: What are the relationships and hierarchical levels of optimal risk control factors in the medical laboratory supply chain using an Interpretive Structural Modeling approach? Theoretical Framework Risk Management Supply chain risk management focuses on controlling risks that affect the efficient flow of information, materials, and products across different segments of the supply chain. Risk management is a key component of supply chain management; and given the diverse objectives within supply chains, it can be utilized when risk is considered a multidimensional phenomenon. Factors such as uncertainty in supply and demand, market globalization, shorter technology and product life cycles, and the increasing use of outsourcing have been identified as major reasons for the importance of supply chain risk management (De Oliveira et al., 2024). Wang et al. (2025), in their study on Strategic Behavior in Multi-Criteria Sorting with a Trust-Relationship-Based Consensus Mechanism: Application to Supply Chain Risk Management, examined strategic behavior using a cost-based consensus mechanism within a social trust network. First, a piecewise cost function dependent on trust relationships was formally defined and formulated, taking into account the influence of trust on preference adjustments required to achieve consensus sorting. Based on this trust-dependent cost structure, a strategic preference manipulation model was proposed to enable strategic behavior in consensus sorting by minimizing the adjustment costs incurred by decision-makers. Considering that the social trust network affects strategic manipulation, an extended collaborative strategic manipulation model was introduced to guide decision-makers in adjusting both their preferences and their social trust networks. Furthermore, the practical applicability of the proposed strategic manipulation models was demonstrated through a supply chain risk management case study, and their performance was validated through simulation analysis. Mobo et al. (2025) investigated Supply Chain Risk Management in the Trade Sector: A Modern Perspective. Their findings indicate that studying supply chain sustainability strategies is crucial, especially when the risks faced by commercial farms within the supply chain are increasingly complex, diverse, and sudden—making prediction and probability assessment more difficult than ever. This underscores the significance of supply chain management. It was found that in order to gain competitive advantages within the market, the trade sector must improve supply chain management practices, which leads to reduced costs from production to delivery, optimized timing, and enhanced customer satisfaction. Their study also concludes that an effective risk assessment mechanism in the supply chain for the trade sector must serve as an appropriate tool for evaluating the effectiveness of risk management from the perspective of all business segments involved in the supply chain. Research Methodology This study was conducted using a mixed-methods approach (qualitative–quantitative) and, in terms of purpose, followed an exploratory and descriptive–survey design. The statistical population consisted of 15 senior managers and experts working in medical laboratories across different stages of the supply chain, selected through the snowball sampling method. Data were collected by semi-structured interviews. Research Findings For data analysis, the Fuzzy Delphi method, Interpretive Structural Modeling (ISM), and MICMAC software were used. The results of the interpretive structural analysis using the exploratory model revealed that the model includes four main factors and thirteen sub-factors distributed across four hierarchical levels. The fourth level involves supply chain risk identification, including financial and legal risks, quality risks, and supplier and logistics risks. The third level consists of failure mode and effects analysis, including identifying weaknesses, analyzing failure impacts, and prioritizing risks. The second level encompasses risk response and management strategies, including supplier diversification, emergency planning, and quality control supported by information technology. Finally, the factors and dimensions identified in the previous three levels lead, at the first level, to achieving optimal risk control, characterized by risk and failure reduction, increased supply chain efficiency, continuous improvement, and performance monitoring. Conclusion The present study aimed to determine the relationships and hierarchical levels of optimal risk control factors in the medical laboratory supply chain using an Interpretive Structural Modeling approach. The results of this research are consistent with the findings of Wang et al. (2025), Mobo et al. (2025), Shishehgarkhaneh et al. (2024), Choudhary et al. (2023), Ganesh & Kalpana (2022), Qaraghanabadi & Sarkardeh (2024), Arab Cham Khalifa & Alavi (2023), and Fokerdi & Talavari (2021). Mobo et al. (2025) demonstrated that an effective risk assessment mechanism in the supply chain for the commercial sector must serve as an appropriate tool for evaluating the effectiveness of risk management from the perspective of all business units involved in the supply chain. Based on the findings of the study, the following recommendations are proposed: Organizations should prioritize reducing risks and preventing failures in order to achieve optimal risk control. Implementing preventive processes, continuously analyzing risks, and executing proactive programs can help reduce the likelihood of failure causes and, in turn, ensure the efficiency and continuity of the supply chain.

Original Article (Quantified) Marketing and Brand Strategy

Validation of the Social Marketing Model for Banking Services with Emphasis on Consumer Behavior Patterns in Rafidain Bank of Iraq

Pages 217-237

https://doi.org/10.22034/jnamm.2026.578955.1264

Aboalhasan Mudhafar Mohammed Alkadhim, naser seyfollahi anar, Ghasem Zarei, Mohammad Bashokouh Ajirloo

Abstract Abstract The aim of the present research is to validate the social marketing model for banking services, emphasizing consumer behavior patterns in Rafidain Bank, Iraq, through testing structural relationships. This research is applicable-developmental in terms of objective, and descriptive-survey in terms of method, employing a quantitative approach. The statistical population of the study consists of 384 customers of Rafidain Bank, Iraq, selected via random sampling. To validate the extracted model, a researcher-made questionnaire was developed and distributed among the statistical population. Data analysis was conducted by AMOS 20 software and Structural Equation Modeling (SEM). The results of this study indicate that at Rafidain Bank, Iraq, contextual conditions play the most significant role in shaping social marketing strategies, while the core phenomenon (consumer behavior patterns) serves a complementary and reinforcing role. This model suggests that the success of social marketing for banking services within the Iraqi context depends more on the degree to which strategies align with the cultural, institutional, and structural realities of society than on merely understanding customer behavior. Introduction A brief review of the performance of the banking market in Iraq indicates that despite the growing trend of financial services and the increasing public awareness of banks, the current status of banking service marketing still shows a considerable gap from the ideal level (Azar et al., 2025). For example, the penetration rate of modern banking services such as digital banking, financial advisory services, and credit instruments remains lower than the global average. This is while in leading countries, a large portion of people’s financial interactions with banks takes place through customer-oriented approaches and social marketing strategies (Babaee et al., 2025). One of the main reasons for this gap, in addition to technical and infrastructural challenges, relates to an insufficient understanding of consumer behavior, lack of attention to the psychological and social preferences of customers, and weaknesses in creating a positive experience in interactions with banks (Babalola et al., 2020). In many cases, banks’ inability to establish effective communication with customers leads to reduced loyalty, trust, and continuous use of banking services. This not only negatively affects the financial performance of banks but also results in negative word-of-mouth advertising and ultimately weakens the banking brand (Baghmalek et al., 2025). Rafidain Bank of Iraq, as one of the largest and most long-standing banks in the country, faces similar challenges (Baicu et al., 2020). Although the bank has made efforts in recent years to modernize its services, the absence of effective social marketing strategies and the neglect of behavioral, cognitive, and emotional dimensions of consumers have prevented the achievement of its intended goals (Biroscak et al., 2025). Under such circumstances, banks need to adopt modern marketing models such as sensory marketing in order to establish deeper and more effective relationships with customers (Borges et al., 2019). Many marketing activities have merely been limited to creating awareness and visual identity, which has little impact on customer loyalty and choice (Dietrich et al., 2022). A strong mental image and a credible brand can be among the most effective tools for creating sustainable differentiation in the banking industry (Enworo, 2023). In addition, a strong brand plays a significant role in reducing customers’ perceived risk and provides banks with a sustainable competitive advantage (Ezechi et al., 2025). Nevertheless, most banks have mainly focused on financial performance and have neglected a deep understanding of customer perceptions and behaviors (Faludi, 2025). This gap in understanding consumer behavior and the weakness in developing effective social marketing represent a fundamental challenge for banks, particularly Rafidain Bank of Iraq. Therefore, the present study aims to design and present a comprehensive model of social marketing for banking services with a particular emphasis on consumer behavior patterns in Rafidain Bank. Through this approach, the bank may enhance its position in the competitive Iraqi market and increase customer satisfaction and loyalty. Accordingly, the main research question of the present study is: How can validate the social marketing model for banking services with an emphasis on consumer behavior patterns in Rafidain Bank of Iraq? Theoretical Framework Social Marketing Social marketing has been defined as the application of marketing principles and tools to achieve desired social objectives, with its aim being the benefit of society rather than personal goals or organizational interests (Kamin et al., 2022). Social marketing is a business perspective that respects the ethics of employees, society, and the environment; and it is a comprehensive strategy capable of improving an organization’s competitive position. Companies and marketing managers should adopt a philosophy based on social responsibility and adherence to ethical principles. This ethical perspective and insight help marketing managers rationally deal with many complex issues faced by marketing and other human activities (Wang, 2023). Kikhah et al. (2025) investigated the role of social marketing in improving bank performance through institutionalized knowledge management opportunities, with a case study of Mehr Iran Qard Al-Hasana Bank branches in Sistan and Baluchestan Province. The analysis of hypotheses utilizing structural equation modeling showed that, in the presence of institutionalized knowledge management, the standardized coefficient for the relationship between social marketing and employee performance increased from 0.502 to 0.617, meaning an increase of over 30% in the standardized coefficient, while remaining significant. Ahmadi and Ghane Bagheri Baghal (2025) examined the impact of social marketing on bank profitability with the moderating role of social responsibility. The results indicated that social marketing is related to bank profitability. Social responsibility moderates the relationship between social marketing and bank profitability. Research Methodology In terms of purpose, this study is applicable–developmental; in terms of method, it is descriptive–survey, with a quantitative approach. The statistical population of the study consisted of 384 customers of Rafidain Bank in Iraq, selected through random sampling. In order to validate the extracted model, a researcher‑made questionnaire was developed and distributed among the statistical population. Research Findings AMOS 20 software and Structural Equation Modeling (SEM) were employed to analyze the research findings. The results of this study indicate that, in Rafidain Bank of Iraq, contextual conditions play the most significant role in shaping social marketing strategies, while the central phenomenon (consumer behavior patterns) plays a complementary and reinforcing role. This model suggests that the success of social marketing for banking services in the Iraqi context depends not merely on understanding customer behavior, but more importantly on the extent to which strategies are aligned with the cultural, institutional, and structural realities of society. Conclusion The present study was conducted with the aim of validating the social marketing model for banking services with an emphasis on consumer behavior patterns in Rafidain Bank of Iraq through the testing of structural relationships. These results are consistent with the findings of Kikhah et al. (2025), Ahmadi & Ghane Bagheri Baghal (2025), Safaei et al. (2025), Nguyen (2025), Haqtalab (2024), Allahyari et al. (2023), Cao & Weerawardena (2023), Onuorah et al. (2022), and Kamin et al. (2022). Haqtalab (2024) demonstrated that social marketing and its dimensions (social marketing mix, pro-social behavior, customer orientation, and nature of services) influence the behavioral reactions of customers in Tejarat Bank branches of Torbat-e Jam. Furthermore, employees’ pro-social behavior and; subsequently, customer orientation have the highest impact and importance. Based on the findings of this research, it is recommended that Rafidain Bank of Iraq place its primary focus on strengthening contextual conditions in the formulation and implementation of social marketing strategies; this includes enhancing institutional trust, aligning marketing messages with the cultural values and norms of Iraqi society, and improving technological and digital infrastructure. Additionally, targeted investment in intervening conditions—such as enhancing customers’ financial literacy, empowering employees in the field of social marketing, and developing interactive digital channels—can significantly increase the effectiveness of these strategies.

Original Article (Mixed) Other topics related to business management, entrepreneurship, and marketing

Analysis of an Organizational Policy Model Based on Corporate Social Responsibility in the National Iranian South Oil Company

https://doi.org/10.22034/jnamm.2026.555464.1188

Mohammadali Nikbakhsh, Ali Bahrekan, Mojtaba Hayati, Saeid Bazouei

Abstract The aim of the present study is to analyze an organizational policy model based on corporate social responsibility in oil‑rich regions companies. In terms of its objective, the research is basic–applied, and in terms of its implementation method, it employs an exploratory mixed-method approach (qualitative–quantitative).The statistical population in the qualitative section consisted of 14 managers and experts in the field of social policy-making and corporate social responsibility, including faculty members and managers of oil‑rich regions companies, who were selected purposively. In the quantitative section, the statistical population included 191 managers and experts of the National Iranian Copper Industries Company who were knowledgeable in the field of corporate social responsibility and were selected through simple random sampling.Data collection tools included semi‑structured interviews in the qualitative phase and a researcher‑made questionnaire in the quantitative phase. For data analysis, the qualitative data were analyzed using the grounded theory method with NVivo version 11, while in the quantitative phase SPSS and PLS software were used.The results of the qualitative phase indicated that the extracted concepts consisted of 89 open codes, 30 axial codes, and 15 selective codes, which together form the model of social policies based on corporate social responsibility in the National Iranian Copper Industries Company.The results of the quantitative phase showed that the causal conditions of the CSR‑based social policy implementation model, contextual factors influencing the model, intervening conditions of CSR‑based social policies, consequences of the CSR‑based social policy model, and strategies of CSR‑based social policies constitute the core categories forming the model of social policies based on corporate social responsibility.

Original Article (Mixed) Marketing Management

Predicting the products needed by e-commerce customers using machine learning algorithms in Kalleh Meat Products Company

https://doi.org/10.22034/jnamm.2026.569389.1240

ahmad firouzi, Hamidreza Razavi, saeid emamgholizadeh, Seyed Hesameddin Motavalli, Mohammadreza Razavi

Abstract Abstract

This research was conducted with the aim of predicting the products needed by e-commerce customers in Kalleh Meat Products Company using machine learning algorithms. The present study is applied in terms of purpose and was carried out with a quantitative approach. The data used included historical online purchase records of Kalleh Company's customers, comprising the variables "product price", "past purchase weight volume", "product type", "past purchase frequency", and "past purchase amount in Rials". To predict the "required product" as the output variable, four machine learning algorithms including Artificial Neural Network (ANN), Random Forest, Decision Tree, and K-Nearest Neighbors (KNN) were implemented and evaluated using Accuracy, Precision, Recall, and F1-Score metrics. The model evaluation results showed that the Artificial Neural Network algorithm achieved the highest scores across all evaluation metrics (Accuracy: 95.1%, Precision: 94.2%, Recall: 95.9%, and F1-Score: 95.5%), indicating that the Artificial Neural Network had the best performance in predicting the products needed by customers. The research models were implemented and validated in the Python 3.x programming environment using specialized libraries Scikit-learn and Keras based on TensorFlow. Subsequently, the Random Forest, Decision Tree, and K-Nearest Neighbors algorithms ranked next, respectively. Moreover, the feature importance analysis revealed that "past purchase weight volume" and "past purchase frequency" had the greatest impact on the model's prediction. The proposed model based on the Artificial Neural Network has the potential to be developed into an accurate and efficient product recommender system for Kalleh Company. Implementation of this model can lead to optimized inventory management, increased customer satisfaction, and ultimately sales growth for the company by accurately predicting future customer demand.

Original Article (Quantified) Marketing Management

Validation of factors affecting the intelligent marketing information system in Refah chain store

https://doi.org/10.22034/jnamm.2026.585563.1313

Hafez Roustasekehravani, Abdullah Naami, Alireza Rousta, Kiamars Fathi Hafshejani

Abstract The objective of this study is to validate the factors influencing the Intelligent Marketing Information System in Refah Chain Stores. In terms of purpose, the study is applied, and its methodological approach is quantitative with a descriptive–survey design. The statistical population consists of 384 managers and experts in marketing and information technology from selected branches of Refah chain stores. The sampling method used in this research is simple random sampling. Data were collected using a researcher-developed questionnaire. To evaluate the fit of the proposed model, Structural Equation Modeling (SEM) was employed using SmartPLS 4 software.The findings of the study indicate that business value strategy, intelligent product management, customer behavior analysis and purchase psychology, intelligent customer communications, responsive logistics and supply chain, intelligent customer experience, data technologies and infrastructures, performance measurement and metrics, organizational adaptability, and ethical and data governance frameworks have a positive and significant impact on the design of an intelligent marketing information system.Consequently, the design and implementation of such a system requires the intelligent integration of advanced analytical technology capabilities with business strategy, ethical considerations, and the preparation of the organizational infrastructure. This research provides an operational framework for managers of Refah chain stores, enabling them to transform data into actionable insights in order not only to enhance operational efficiency and profitability but also to effectively fulfill their social role in ensuring the adequate supply of essential goods for society.

Original Article (Quantified) Marketing and Brand Strategy

Proposing an Artificial Intelligence Model for Rafidain Bank Based on Enhancing Marketing Capability Assurance

https://doi.org/10.22034/jnamm.2026.578952.1263

Nagham Khalid Abdulameer Alrubaye, Hossein Rahimi Kolour, Mohammad Bashokouh Ajirloo, Ghasem Zarei

Abstract The banking sector is undergoing a fundamental transformation driven by the integration of artificial intelligence into financial service processes. AI enhances operational efficiency, risk management, and customer interaction. Accordingly, the present study was conducted with the aim of developing an AI‑based model for Rafidain Bank, supported by the assurance of strengthened marketing capabilities, using an emergent grounded‑theory strategy.

The study population consisted of fifteen Rafidain Bank managers and experts, along with academic elites in Iraq, who were selected through snowball sampling and participated in semi‑structured interviews. The collected data were analyzed through three stages of open, axial, and selective coding, using MAXQDA 2024 and relying on latent content analysis techniques.

The findings led to the development of conceptual categories including AI adaptability, AI sustainability, AI user experience, AI capability, the bank’s future‑orientation, AI knowledge, and effective bank performance, resulting in ten novel core hypotheses among these constructs.

The results demonstrate that AI‑driven marketing capabilities are becoming increasingly prominent and serve as the primary antecedents of effective performance for Rafidain Bank in this study.

Original Article (Mixed) Other topics related to business management, entrepreneurship, and marketing

Identifying and Prioritizing Factors Affecting the Success and Failure of Platform Ecosystems in Technology Companies

https://doi.org/10.22034/jnamm.2026.582905.1298

Shahrzad Vosooghi, Ahmad Foroutan, Mahboobe Salehi

Abstract The objective of the present study is to identify and prioritize the factors influencing the success and failure of platform ecosystems in technology firms. The research method, in line with its purpose, is applied–developmental, and in terms of its nature, follows an exploratory mixed‑method design (qualitative–quantitative). The statistical population includes 15 industry and academic experts in the qualitative phase and 12 experts in the quantitative phase. A semi‑structured interview was used as the data collection instrument. For data analysis, thematic analysis was conducted in MAXQDA 2024 in the qualitative phase, and in the quantitative phase, the factors were prioritized using the fuzzy analytic hierarchy process (FAHP). Four‑scenario sensitivity analysis and Friedman and Spearman tests were employed to validate the robustness of the results.Findings from the qualitative phase indicate that 36 open codes, 12 sub‑themes, and ultimately 6 success factors and 6 failure factors were identified. The quantitative results show that the most important success factors are, respectively, “positive network effects” (weight = 0.382), “transparent and fair governance” (0.245), and “effective complementor management” (0.163). Conversely, the key failure factors consist of “multi‑homing migration” (0.351), “unsustainable revenue model” (0.228), and “negative network effects” (0.175). The consistency ratios of the matrices (CR = 0.05 for success and CR = 0.07 for failure) indicate acceptable reliability in the judgments.A three‑layer integrated framework was proposed comprising, for success: foundational prerequisites, core drivers, and sustaining mechanisms; and for failure: primary threat, structural threats, and contextual threats. Platform managers should prioritize strengthening positive network effects, enhancing governance transparency, and mitigating multi‑homing migration.

Original Article (Mixed) Other topics related to business management, entrepreneurship, and marketing

Designing a Competition Model for Streaming Platforms (Subscription-Based Video and Audio Services) with an Emphasis on the Future of Media Management

https://doi.org/10.22034/jnamm.2026.582911.1299

Fatemeh Piravi Vanak, Saeed Hemmati Alvandi

Abstract The present study aims to design a model of competition among streaming platforms (subscription-based video and audio services), with an emphasis on the future of media management. In terms of purpose, the research is applied, and in terms of implementation, it adopts a mixed-methods design (qualitative–quantitative) using a sequential exploratory approach.The statistical population in the qualitative phase consisted of 15 experts in the field of media management in Iran. In the quantitative phase, the statistical population included 378 active users of streaming services in Iran (Filimo, Namava, ShadAva, and BeepTunes), and the sampling method employed in this study was convenience sampling.The data collection instruments were semi-structured interviews and a questionnaire. For data analysis, qualitative data were examined through coding (including the three stages of basic, organizing, and global themes) using MAXQDA software, while quantitative data were analyzed through structural equation modeling using the partial least squares approach (PLS-SEM).The findings revealed that the three dominant competitive models were the production of exclusive local content, bundling with mobile network operators, and a hybrid advertising-subscription model. The phenomenon of multi-homing was observed among more than three-quarters of users and showed a positive and significant correlation with churn rate. The results of the PLS modeling indicated that bundling with mobile operators had the greatest effect on reducing churn.Qualitative analysis identified seven main categories. The most likely future scenarios include the merger and alliance of platforms or the stabilization of existing platforms. It is concluded that media managers should adopt a combination of customer retention strategies and prepare themselves to manage integrated, large-scale platforms.

Original Article (Qualitative) Human resource management

Designing a Dynamic Model of Green Human Resource Management in Organizations

Articles in Press, Accepted Manuscript, Available Online from 21 December 2026

https://doi.org/10.22034/jnamm.2026.582225.1291

Ali‑Akbar Hosseinnia Miri, Jamshid Salar

Abstract The present research aims to design a dynamic model for Green Human Resource Management (GHRM) within organizations. In terms of purpose, this study is applied-developmental, and methodologically, it is a qualitative-exploratory research. The study population consists of 15 academic experts and senior human resource managers, selected through snowball sampling. Data were collected via semi-structured interviews and analyzed using thematic analysis with MAXQDA software, following the process of open, axial, and selective coding. The findings revealed that the dynamic GHRM model comprises six key dimensions: “Green Competencies,” “Environmental Organizational Culture,” “Green Management Support,” “Green Job Engagement,” “Sustainable Performance Feedback,” and “Structural Flexibility.” The analysis of themes and the network of codes indicate that these dimensions operate as a continuous learning-interactive cycle rather than a linear progression; they enhance organizational sustainability through feedback mechanisms, adaptive processes, and cultural institutionalization. By providing a qualitative and contextualized model, this research fills the existing theoretical gap in GHRM literature and offers a conceptual roadmap for the systematic, adaptive, and sustainable implementation of this approach in organizations within developing contexts.

Original Article (Quantified) Marketing and Brand Strategy

The impact of social media communication on brand equity with mediating role of e-WOM and moderaing role of product involvement

Articles in Press, Accepted Manuscript, Available Online from 21 December 2026

https://doi.org/10.22034/jnamm.2026.584405.1310

Mohammad mahdi Dehghani tafti, Alireza Moghaddasi

Abstract In today's highly competitive markets, managers are looking to make people aware of their products and improve their brand. One of these methods is social media, which has created a great transformation in the field of business and electronic marketing. Brand equity is a valuable but intangible asset of any company, understanding brand equity is a major task for many organizations. Therefore, the purpose of this research was to investigate the impact of social media communication on brand equity through the mediation of electronic verbal advertising and the moderation of product mental involvement. The statistical population of the current research were dairy products customers of Yazd province who have used its products for at least one year and are present on social media, whose exact number is not known. Therefore, the number of members is 384 and is considered available by sampling method. The data collection tool was a questionnaire taken from the research of Lin et al. (2023). Convergent and divergent validity and factor analysis were used to measure face validity according to experts and regarding construct validity. Cronbach's alpha and composite reliability were used to measure reliability. Data analysis was done with SmartPLS3 software. The results showed that the co Firm-generated content as well as the user has a significant impact on electronic word of mouth and brand equity. The effect of electronic word of mouth on brand equity was significant. The Firm-generated content and the user has been significant through the mediating role of electronic word of mouth on brand equity. Finally, the role of moderator of product involvement in the relationship between the Firm-generated content, and the user and the brand equity.

Original Article (Quantified) Marketing and Brand Strategy

Investigating the Effect of Brand Reputation through Emotional Attachment on Brand Advocacy among Customers of Non-Iranian Luxury Car Brands with Respect to the Role of Experience and Price

Articles in Press, Accepted Manuscript, Available Online from 21 December 2026

https://doi.org/10.22034/jnamm.2026.582204.1293

ali yavari, shiva savabieh

Abstract The present study investigated the effect of brand reputation on brand advocacy among customers of non-Iranian luxury car brands, considering the mediating role of emotional attachment as well as the moderating role of customer experience and price perception. This research is applied in terms of purpose and quantitative-descriptive survey in terms of method. The statistical population consisted of 180 customers of non-Iranian luxury car brands in Yazd city, who responded to the questions of a questionnaire derived from reputable international studies using simple random probability sampling. Data analysis was performed using structural equation modeling with PLS software. The findings showed that brand reputation has a significant indirect effect on brand advocacy through increased emotional attachment, while the moderating role of brand experience and price perception was not confirmed. This finding indicates the predominance of emotional factors over economic and experiential factors in shaping brand advocacy among customers of non-Iranian luxury car brands.

Entrepreneurship

Freelancing: A New Approach to Entrepreneurship and Business: A Thematic Analysis of Paths, Challenges, and Economic Empowerment Through Freelancing

Volume 5, Issue 1, Spring 2026, Pages 23-44

https://doi.org/10.22034/jnamm.2026.564097.1219

Ali Siahkolah, Mohammad Hossein Foroozanfar

Abstract Abstract
This study aims to examine the experiences and influential factors shaping young people’s transitions from traditional employment to freelancing. The statistical population consists of 28 Iranian experts in the field of freelancing. Data were collected through semi‑structured interviews using purposive sampling and continued until theoretical saturation was reached. The qualitative method applied in this study was thematic analysis based on Braun and Clarke’s standard framework, and coding and analysis were conducted using Atlas.ti software.
The analysis of findings revealed four strategic dimensions that provide a comprehensive perspective for understanding freelancing:
(1) push factors and decision‑making in career transition;
(2) significant economic and financial challenges during the transition process;
(3) skill development and professional networking; and
(4) economic empowerment outcomes for youth.
The results indicate that transitioning from traditional employment to freelancing is a complex and multilayered process requiring precise and purposeful planning, strong social and professional network development, and the establishment of supportive governmental and political environments. The comprehensive strategic framework presented in this study can serve as a practical and evidence‑based guide for policymakers, entrepreneurs, and stakeholder organizations—including chambers of commerce and labor unions—to more effectively support young individuals during this career transition and to improve conditions for the development of freelancing.
Introduction
Over the past decade, a transformative shift—both morphological and structural—has emerged in the global labor market, placing independent entrepreneurship and freelancing at the forefront as key solutions. In Iran, as the knowledge‑based economy, modern digital technologies, and internet‑driven economic infrastructures rapidly expand and evolve (Khodaparast & Emadi, 2025), young people are increasingly and noticeably gravitating toward freelancing, autonomous work, and self‑directed employment, considering these pathways as preferred career choices.
These new forms of employment and career transitions, despite offering advantages such as flexibility and autonomy, are accompanied by complex and profound challenges that pose difficulties both for young individuals and for the global economy (Yang et al., 2024). Income instability, lack of access to conventional employment benefits such as health insurance and unemployment insurance, high levels of economic vulnerability, and the absence of formal support structures are among the most significant challenges (Lu et al., 2024).
Accordingly, the central research question is formulated as follows: How does the transition of Iranian youth from traditional employment to freelancing lead to economic empowerment?
Theoretical Foundations
Independent Entrepreneurship
Independent entrepreneurship, or freelancing, refers to a modern approach to business and autonomous work in which an individual, as an independent entrepreneur, undertakes various projects for multiple clients. In this model, the individual operates as a self‑directed professional, performing diverse tasks for different and numerous clients (Baitenizov et al., 2025; Öberg, 2018).
Career Path
Various perspectives exist regarding career paths, each emphasizing one or several dimensions of occupational development. Holland’s Theory of Career Choice highlights the alignment between an individual’s personality and their work environment, proposing that people are naturally drawn to occupations that match their personality types—such as realistic, investigative, artistic, social, enterprising, or conventional. This theory conceptualizes career choice primarily as a voluntary and individually driven process based on person‑environment fit; however, it pays limited attention to external pressures and involuntary career transitions.
Economic Empowerment
Economic empowerment is a broad and multi-layered concept that refers to the process by which individuals acquire and activate the ability, authority, and capacity to plan, make independent decisions, and control their own economic resources (Golara et al., 2025; Saffari Darberazi et al., 2025).
Research Methodology
This qualitative study employed the thematic analysis method within the standard framework developed by Braun and Clarke (2006), utilizing the Atlas.ti software. A qualitative approach was selected for this research to gain an in-depth, internal understanding of the lived experiences, motivations, emotions, and meanings held by participants (Clarke & Braun, 2021). This established framework for thematic analysis has garnered over 20,000 academic citations to date and represents a scientific and systematic method for identifying semantic patterns and latent themes within qualitative data (Foroozanfar et al., 2025).
The study utilized purposive sampling. The statistical population comprised individuals holding at least a bachelor’s degree and currently engaged in freelance work. In this research, the criterion for concluding the sampling process was the achievement of theoretical saturation, as defined within Braun and Clarke’s (2006) thematic analysis framework. The sampling process unfolded iteratively and in parallel with the coding phase. Following approximately 22 initial interviews, no significant new codes were added to the initial coding structure, and the primary themes began to repeat. Subsequently, conducting 6 additional interviews provided richer data and new contextual examples but did not yield any novel conceptual codes or themes, indicating theoretical saturation at the level of the main themes.
Research Findings
Through the analysis of 28 interviews conducted with the target population and audience, followed by a textual analysis of the interview transcripts, 11 initial themes were identified. In aggregate, these sub-themes represent four main dimensions, illustrating that the transition from traditional employment to freelancing among Iranian youth is not a simple linear process. Instead, it is a chain of transitions where push factors and liberating motivations, in conjunction with economic and institutional challenges, are navigated through skill and network development. This ultimately leads to outcomes of relative empowerment or [outcome not specified in text]. Consequently, freelancing in this study is understood not merely as an opportunity nor solely as a threat, but as a dynamic and conditional field whose quality of experience is contingent upon a specific combination of individual, network, and structural circumstances.
Discussion and Conclusion
The results of this research indicate that the transition from traditional, conventional employment to freelancing for Iranian youth is a complex, multi-layered, and arduous process that demands considerable attention, meticulous and purposeful planning, and substantial support. The key findings are as follows: Firstly, diverse and varying push factors are significant—negative push factors (fear of instability, dissatisfaction) are as important as positive ones (freedom, income). Secondly, considerable economic challenges, such as income instability and the lack of benefits, represent fundamental dilemmas requiring innovative solutions. Thirdly, essential social capital, along with strong professional and social networks are crucial for success and economic empowerment. Fourthly, balanced economic empowerment and genuine self-sufficiency necessitate a combination of financial independence, a sense of control, and economic security.
In comparison to previous research, the findings of this study regarding the importance of networking underscore the vital and fundamental role of social capital in freelancing. These results corroborate Golara’s (2025) research on the role of “weak ties” and professional networks in job seeking. Furthermore, our findings concerning the essential role of social and professional networks, the importance of continuous skill development and learning, and the fear and concern regarding income instability show significant similarities with studies conducted in other countries (Baitenizov et al., 2019; Morris et al., 2025). However, fundamental differences also exist. It can be argued that in Iran, negative push factors are stronger, whereas in developed countries, positive factors are more prevalent.
The findings of this research have important implications for policymakers and support organizations, presented below based on the study’s outcomes:
Based on the findings and themes from the push factors and decision-making dimension, a significant portion of youth transitioning to freelancing stems from dissatisfaction with the rigid structures and bureaucracy of traditional employment. Therefore, it is recommended that governmental and private organizations revise their human resource policies. By developing flexible work models (remote work, flextime, project-based work) and reducing unnecessary procedures, they can mitigate some of the push pressures. This would help transform freelancing from an option often driven by compulsion or escape from structure into a conscious and strategic choice.
Based on the themes from the economic challenges dimension, considering the fundamental role of income instability and the lack of benefits in undermining the economic empowerment of freelancers, it is proposed that policymaking institutions such as the Ministry of Labor, the Social Security Organization, and the Chamber of Commerce move towards designing insurance and support mechanisms tailored for freelancers. This includes flexible health and retirement insurance and adaptable premiums based on actual income, thereby partially reducing the gap between occupational freedom and social security.
Furthermore, findings based on the skill development and networking dimension indicated that success in freelancing depends on a package of technical, soft, and business skills, as well as robust professional networks. Consequently, it is recommended that universities, skill training centers, and science and technology parks design and implement comprehensive freelancing preparation courses, including training in negotiation, project management, personal marketing, and professional networking skills. They should also foster the development of social capital for freelancers by creating networking spaces, such as internal events and platforms.
Also, based on the themes from the economic empowerment outcomes, given that economic empowerment is experienced as relative and conditional by participants, it is suggested that policymakers and freelancing platforms develop indicators to monitor the quality of freelance livelihoods, including relative income stability and access to social support. Based on these indicators, programs to enhance the welfare and job security of freelancers should be designed, ensuring that the transition to freelancing systematically leads to improved well-being rather than merely a change in the form of insecure work.
Based on the results of this research, suggestions for other researchers interested in the field of freelancing are presented as follows: conducting longitudinal studies to track the career paths of youth over longer periods; examining the potential of freelancing for women and conducting specific research on the unique barriers faced by female freelancers; analyzing the role of new technologies, artificial intelligence, and automation on the future of freelancing; investigating public sector support policies; conducting cross-country comparative studies to benchmark and assess efficient and diverse freelancing methods; and examining the social effects of freelancing on family and social relationships.

A review of supply chain performance evaluation models - case study: Iranian auto parts supply chain

Volume 1, Issue 1, March 2023, Pages 99-108

https://doi.org/10.22034/jnamm.2023.423043.1020

Fatemeh saghafi, Massoud Rezaei, Mohammad Mehdi Rezaei

Abstract In the current competitive conditions, the proper performance of the supply chain plays a key role in the success of an organization and the achievement of its goals, especially its profitability, therefore, in recent years, the management and measurement of supply chain performance has attracted the attention of a large number of managers and researchers in this study. In line with supply chain performance evaluation, various performance evaluation methods have been introduced and the characteristics of the most famous methods and studies conducted in this field have been collected. In this article, a framework for choosing the best method of evaluation of supply chain performance, improvement and continuous evaluation is proposed, which can facilitate the evaluation process in a targeted manner. It is suggested that in the next works, a review study on each of the used supply chain performance evaluation methods is done separately and also a conceptual framework of the application of these methods for different environments is prepared.

The Impact of Customer Experience of Artificial Intelligence on Customer E-satisfaction, Customer Trust in Online Shopping, and Customer Online Purchase Intention in the Insurance Industry

Volume 3, Issue 4, Winter 2025, Pages 1-21

https://doi.org/10.22034/jnamm.2025.490323.1062

seyyedmojtaba mirfazli, Haniyeh Taghizadeh Fashkche, Neda Mohammadpour Khabazi, hassan gharibi

Abstract Abstract The aim of this study is to investigate the impact of customer experience of artificial intelligence on customer electronic satisfaction, customer trust in online shopping, and customer online shopping intention. The statistical population of this study consists of customers of Alborz Insurance Company throughout Iran. The sampling method was non-randomly available and the electronic questionnaire was distributed among customers through social networks (Telegram, ETA, and Instagram) by the admin of Alborz Insurance agencies. After collecting 385 questionnaires, the distribution process was stopped. The data collection tool was a standard questionnaire with 18 customer-specific questions, the validity and reliability of which have been confirmed. The collected data were analyzed using descriptive statistics and inferential statistics. Frequency and frequency percentage indices were used at the descriptive statistics level; and Pearson correlation coefficient, structural equation model, and path analysis were used at the inferential statistics level. For this purpose, SPSS and LISREL software were used. The results of the analyses showed that customer experience of artificial intelligence has a positive and significant effect on all three research variables, namely electronic satisfaction, customer trust in online shopping, and online shopping intention. The highest effect, with a path coefficient of 0.81, was related to the effect of customer experience of artificial intelligence on online shopping intention. In general, artificial intelligence, while improving the quality of customer experience, has a significant effect on key variables in online consumer behavior. Introduction Today, with the spread of information technology in the world and its rapid entry into everyday life, e-business has replaced traditional methods. In the last few years, the growth of cyberspace and businesses that operate on the Internet has been reported to be multifold, which has also led to the expansion of Internet-based commercial activities. The Internet has become a key tool, which can be called a strategic weapon by anybody; a tool that can simultaneously increase consumer trust and answer their questions, given the current competitive environment (Scott, 2015). The Internet has created a wide horizon for business, especially electronic services worldwide. Retailer websites are an important interface between retailers (banks and insurers) and their customers (van de Ven, K., & Koenraadt, R, 2017). Internet and online businesses offer different products and services compared with traditional businesses. Because of the product choices available on the Internet, advertising on social networks is important in enabling customers to make purchasing decisions (Wang et al., 2016). Although the impact of AI in the insurance industry may not be as tangible as in agriculture, cancer diagnosis, military industries, automotive, construction, etc., it can be claimed that this technology has given speed, accuracy, and security to industries such as banking, information technology, insurance, etc. One of the biggest challenges in this field can be considered detecting complex frauds and discovering false claims in the insurance industry. These frauds include fake accidents, arson, false stolen property, multiple repair and medical bills, etc. By using AI in the insurance industry, operational efficiency can be improved, wrongly paid claims can be limited, total payments can be reduced, and the company's profits can be increased. By relying on AI, insurance companies can consider more competitive prices for their insurance products and offer more personalized services to their customers. In the past, insurers needed customer information to assess insurance risks, although in some cases, due to the dishonesty of individuals, incorrect risk assessment was not possible. But now, with the advancement of machine learning and artificial intelligence, insurers have access to more accurate information sources. For example, in the housing sector, insurance companies can use artificial intelligence to obtain information about the geographical location, marital status and the likelihood of claiming damages from individuals. Also, today, technological developments, especially in the field of telecommunications and information technology, have revolutionized the industry of providing online services such as mobile applications and smartphones. This has changed customer satisfaction from traditional satisfaction to electronic satisfaction, and companies should pay attention to electronic satisfaction in addition to physical satisfaction of customers when measuring customer satisfaction. In fact, the importance of customer satisfaction in an electronic and service environment has been confirmed by marketing studies (Al-dweeri et al., 2017). Satisfaction leads to strong repurchase behavior in the future and also leads to increased sales and profits of the organization and improves the market value for an organization. In the offline environment, customer satisfaction is defined as an emotional reaction in response to one or more cognitive service encounters (Gera, 2011). It is a reaction that occurs immediately after the point of purchase of products and services (Behjati et al., 2012). In the online context, e-customer satisfaction is defined as the consumer's perceptions of online convenience, commerce, website design, and financial security (Ilgaz, H., & Gülbahar, Y., 2015). Therefore, these days, customers are changing their behaviors dramatically in line with the technology and economic environment of the world. They are acquiring a large amount of information, are familiar with products, and are losing their trust in advertisements. They prefer customized products and services, and change their purchasing channels; therefore, businesses are forced to modify or even change their advertising strategies to cope with the changes, facts, and behaviors of their customers in order to survive (Cui et al., 2018). One of the most common beliefs that consumers have about online shopping is that this type of shopping saves time and money and helps them find products that better match their needs (Punj, 2011). Online shopping decisions are directly influenced by consumers' emotions and their online shopping beliefs about the attractiveness of the website or mobile applications and the style of communication with the e-commerce software with the customer. These emotions and beliefs are vital elements of the image of an online store or mobile application in the minds of customers and are thus able to be a stimulus for online shopping (Alnawas, I., & Aburub, F, 2016, gharibi et al., 2019). Therefore, it can be said that there is a need for research and study in the insurance industry so that insurance companies can study the impact of artificial intelligence on customer trust, attitude and behavior. Therefore, the question of the present research is: What is the impact of customer experience of artificial intelligence on customer e-satisfaction, customer trust in online shopping and customer online shopping intention in the insurance industry? Research literature Concept of artificial intelligence Artificial intelligence is a branch of computer science that attempts to understand the nature of intelligence and produce new intelligent machines that think, respond and perform tasks exactly like humans based on the data given to it. Some activities related to artificial intelligence, such as robotics, speech recognition, image recognition, natural language processing and problem solving, are very technical and specialized. Artificial intelligence refers to the intelligence and capabilities used by machines and computer systems to perform intelligent activities and make decisions. This metadata allows machines to recognize patterns, analyze data, and manage problems (Umamaheswari, S., & Valarmathi, A, 2023). Artificial intelligence is concerned with building computer systems and robots that can understand and learn from their observations. The goal of artificial intelligence is to make machines act like humans. The goal of artificial intelligence in general is to build a machine that can “think” (Al-Sayyed et al., 2021). Artificial intelligence includes a set of techniques and algorithms that enable machines to examine and analyze data, identify hidden patterns in them, and make decisions based on them. Artificial intelligence is a branch of computer science that, inspired by sciences such as cognitive psychology, philosophy, logic, statistics and mathematics, tries to simulate a type of human intelligence and does this through software development (Poole, D. L., & Mackworth, A. K, 2010). Electronic satisfaction  High electronic satisfaction is the key to the success of any retailer operating in the competitive global e-commerce environment. To overcome the barriers to global online shopping, companies must improve satisfaction with their electronic services. Most experienced and successful companies in e-commerce have understood that the success factors are not just the company's presence on the web or low prices, but the delivery of high-quality electronic service. Recent research shows that online customers are willing to pay even higher prices for high-quality electronic services offered by electronic retailers; therefore, online retailers should focus on high-quality e-services during and after the transaction rather than on the transaction itself, in order to build customer trust, loyalty, and retention (Navimipour, N. J., & Soltani, Z, 2016). Trust in online shopping Previous studies also show that lack of customer trust is a major barrier to using online shopping. Internet users do not have sufficient trust in sharing and exchanging information and communication with online sellers (Dwidienawati et al., 2020). Perceived ease of use by the customer plays an indirect role in individuals' intentions to adopt or continue to use e-banking. Another study also found that ease of use has an indirect effect on the use of e-banking as much as initial training (Guriting & Ndubisi, 2006). If a person is familiar with the Internet and uses it regularly, they are likely to have a higher level of organizational trust than someone who has not had previous experience using the Internet. As a result, the experience of using the Internet will increase organizational trust (Eastlick, M. A., & Lotz, S, 2011). Customer Online Shopping Behavior Online shopping environments are specific types of interactions that users turn to fulfill their shopping goals. Online shopping is an activity beyond making a mere purchase and includes skills such as searching for products, working with a computer, etc. (Demangeot, C., & Broderick, A. J, 2007). Online shopping intention, as the most important predictor of actual shopping behavior, refers to the outcome of customers' evaluation of criteria such as website quality, information search, and product evaluation (Martins et al., 2023). Conclusion and Discussion The present study, which was conducted among Alborz Insurance customers across Iran, examined the effect of customer experience of artificial intelligence on customer e-satisfaction, customer trust in online shopping, and customer online shopping intention in the insurance industry. The result of the first hypothesis of the study: Customer experience of artificial intelligence has an effect on customer e-satisfaction in the insurance industry. a) Using the Pearson test, the correlation coefficient of customer experience of artificial intelligence and customer e-satisfaction in the insurance industry is 0.75, which indicates a positive and significant effect of customer experience of artificial intelligence on customer e-satisfaction in the insurance industry. b) Considering the path coefficient of 0.78 and the t-statistic of 16.84, it can be said that at a 99% confidence level, customer experience of artificial intelligence has a positive and significant effect on customer e-satisfaction in the insurance industry. The results of this hypothesis are consistent with the studies of Chen et al., (2021); Prentice et al., (2020); Datt (2020); and Hudong (2023). The result of the second hypothesis of the research: Customer experience of artificial intelligence has an effect on customer trust in online shopping in the insurance industry. A) Using the Pearson test, the correlation coefficient between customer experience of artificial intelligence and customer trust in online shopping in the insurance industry is 0.73, which indicates a positive and significant effect of customer experience of artificial intelligence on customer trust in online shopping in the insurance industry. B) Considering the path coefficient of 0.72 and the t-statistic of 11.63, it can be said: At a 99% confidence level, customer experience of artificial intelligence has a positive and significant effect on customer trust in online shopping in the insurance industry. The results of this hypothesis are consistent with the studies of Chen et al., (2021); Prentice et al., (2020); Datt (2020); and Hudong (2023). The result of the third hypothesis of the research: Customer experience of artificial intelligence has an effect on customer online shopping behavior in the insurance industry. a) Using the Pearson test, the correlation coefficient between these two variables is 0.81, which indicates a positive and significant effect of customer experience from artificial intelligence on customer online shopping behavior in the insurance industry. b) Considering the path coefficient of 0.81 and the t-statistic of 19.00, it can be said that at a 99% confidence level, customer experience from artificial intelligence has a positive and significant effect on customer online shopping behavior in the insurance industry. The results of this hypothesis are consistent with the studies of Chen et al., (2021); Prentice et al., (2020); Datt (2020); and Hudong (2023). The result of the fourth hypothesis of the research: Customer e-satisfaction has an effect on customer trust in online shopping in the insurance industry. a) Using the Pearson test, the correlation coefficient between these two variables is 0.68, which indicates a positive and significant effect of customer e-satisfaction on customer trust in online shopping in the insurance industry. b) Considering the path coefficient of 0.69 and the t-statistic of 12.06, it can be said that: at a confidence level of 99 percent, electronic customer satisfaction has a positive and significant effect on customer trust in online shopping in the insurance industry. The results of this hypothesis are consistent with the studies of Chen et al., (2021); and Keshiri et al., (2024). The result of the fifth hypothesis of the research: Electronic customer satisfaction has an effect on customer online shopping behavior in the insurance industry. a) Using the Pearson test, the correlation coefficient between these two variables is 0.79, which indicates a positive and significant effect of electronic customer satisfaction on customer online shopping behavior in the insurance industry. b) Considering the path coefficient of 0.66 and the t-statistic of 41.52, it can be said that: at a confidence level of 99 percent, electronic customer satisfaction has a positive and significant effect on customer online shopping behavior in the insurance industry. The results of this hypothesis are consistent with the studies of Chen et al., (2021); and Keshiri et al., (2024). The result of the sixth hypothesis of the research: Customer trust in online shopping has an effect on customer online shopping behavior in the insurance industry. A) Using the Pearson test, the correlation coefficient between these two variables is 0.75, which indicates a positive and significant effect of customer trust in online shopping on customer online shopping behavior in the insurance industry. B) Considering the path coefficient of 0.64 and the t-statistic of 8.46, it can be said that at a 99% confidence level, customer trust in online shopping has a positive and significant effect on customer online shopping behavior in the insurance industry. The results of this hypothesis are consistent with the studies of Chen et al., (2021); Keshiri et al., (2024); Hemmadi (2023); and Rahmani & Nowzari Jadid (2023). Today, with the spread of internet services and service applications, people of all tastes can compare and purchase different insurance services and, depending on their personal tastes, be satisfied or dissatisfied with their purchase. This satisfaction or dissatisfaction in receiving insurance services is recorded in the form of ratings and comments on mobile applications and social networks, based on which other people purchase services from different insurance companies. Therefore, customer trust and satisfaction with receiving services and even the way in which services are received can affect the customer's intention to purchase online, as in the present study, electronic satisfaction with a path coefficient of 0.66 and online trust with a path coefficient of 0.64 had an effect on the intention to purchase online of Alborz Insurance customers. The time is over when company messages were only about services or products and information was published unilaterally by the company and only what the company wanted to share. With the increasing spread of the Internet in various aspects of life, much research has been conducted to support the encouragement of customers to shop in the electronic and online environment. Considering the characteristics of the electronic environment and the behavioral characteristics of customers, in order to facilitate the customer shopping process, the reasons that cause customer distrust or poor site design and, as a result, customers' lack of purchase in the electronic environment should be investigated and resolved. By relying on the features of challengeability, uninterrupted analysis, the possibility of receiving feedback in time, establishing system interaction, and creating mental images in the electronic and online environment, it is possible to direct the mental structure of customers towards shopping on the Internet and mobile phones and guide their purchase decision-making process. Therefore, considering the impact of customer experience with artificial intelligence on customer e-satisfaction, customer trust in online shopping, and customer online shopping intention in the insurance industry, Alborz Insurance Company offers the following solutions in this regard: Alborz Insurance Company should design a mobile application for itself with the necessary investment in innovation and quick access, and place accessible user guides as a guide to using self-service technology on its website; it is suggested that a section be set up as an online support on the Alborz Insurance website so that it can answer customer questions 24 hours a day, because some customers may work night shifts and use the Alborz Insurance website more often during these times.

business management

Factors affecting the adoption of artificial intelligence in e-commerce by small and medium-sized enterprises

Volume 4, Issue 1, Spring 2025, Pages 62-83

https://doi.org/10.22034/jnamm.2025.500793.1067

Keyhaneh Karimi, Elaheh Mahmoodi Ranani

Abstract Abstract
The aim of this study is to evaluate the factors affecting the adoption of artificial intelligence in e-commerce by small and medium enterprises. This study is applicable in terms of its purpose, and is a quantitative research type. The present study proposes an integrated model based on the framework of dynamic capabilities, entrepreneurial orientation, and customer-centric systems. The empirical data of this study were collected through a digital survey using a purposive sampling method from small and medium enterprises in Iran. The analysis of the collected data was performed using structural equation modeling, and the results point to the role of dynamic capabilities and entrepreneurial orientation in facilitating the adoption of artificial intelligence in e-commerce. The data of this study were collected by distributing an online questionnaire to a sample of 183 decision-makers and managers in small and medium enterprises in Iran working in e-commerce. This study confirms the positive impact of AI adoption on the business performance of SMEs. The findings show that AI adoption in e-commerce is significantly associated with improved business performance of SMEs. Also, this study emphasizes the pivotal role of dynamic capabilities and entrepreneurial orientation in driving AI adoption in the e-commerce sector, which in turn can help improve business performance. These results emphasize the importance of developing technological capabilities and innovative approaches in SMEs to effectively utilize AI and achieve growth and success.
Introduction
Many companies are looking to leverage e-commerce to increase sales, improve services, and achieve greater customer satisfaction. If successful e-commerce strategies and tools are effectively implemented, this technology can significantly increase the revenue and profits of SMEs (Abbas et al., 2023; Ojha et al., 2023). However, the success of using these platforms depends on the level of commitment and trust of companies in smart technologies, which are effective in improving technical services and enhancing customer experience (Mishra et al., 2023). The adoption of artificial intelligence in e-commerce is considered one of the key factors for the success of businesses, as this technology uses existing data to identify opportunities and improve products and services (Liu et al., 2024).
While several studies have addressed the role of artificial intelligence in e-commerce, including customer service, sales facilitation, and information gathering, research related to the adoption and enhancement of artificial intelligence tools in maintaining e-commerce performance and supporting entrepreneurship in small and medium-sized enterprises is still scarce. Therefore, this article seeks to examine the factors affecting the adoption of artificial intelligence in e-commerce in small and medium-sized enterprises to promote entrepreneurship and strengthen the role of these companies in the country's economic progress and development. Insufficient understanding of how SMEs effectively use AI tools in e-commerce can negatively impact their ability to gain competitive advantage. Hence, there is a need for more in-depth research to identify challenges, exploit opportunities, and improve the effectiveness of using these technologies (Salah & Ayash, 2024(.
This paper identifies the benefits and opportunities for SMEs to adopt AI systems in e-commerce and suggests various ways to implement effective strategies for entrepreneurship development and selecting appropriate AI tools. The following key research question is formulated to guide the research and provide a structured approach to understanding the various factors involved: What factors influence SMEs’ ​​adoption of AI in e-commerce?
Theoretical literature
Artificial Intelligence
Artificial Intelligence is a branch of computer science that aims to design systems that can automatically and intelligently process information and perform various tasks. By imitating human intelligence and abilities such as learning, reasoning, problem solving, natural language understanding, and pattern recognition; this technology helps humans solve the most complex scientific, industrial, and social challenges. Artificial intelligence has been recognized as one of the most revolutionary technologies of the modern era since its early years and has now penetrated all aspects of human life (Simone, 2018.)
E-commerce
E-commerce is defined as the electronic buying and selling of items by consumers and businesses using computerized business exchanges. In this study, e-commerce is defined as the buying and selling of transactions over the Internet (Esare et al., 2012). E-commerce allows businesses to grow more easily in the global market and opens up new ways for companies to communicate information with consumers, suppliers, and other stakeholders (Tai, 2022).
Small and Medium Enterprises
In recent years, the importance and role of small and medium enterprises have been increasing, both in industrialized and developing countries. With the advent of new technologies, there have been transformations in production and the methods of it, distribution, and organizational structure of companies. It is essential for small and medium enterprises to use AI tools to obtain maximum value and competitive advantage, which includes reducing human errors, analyzing customer data, and providing highly efficient services. AI also helps in providing new and intelligent innovations that serve both institutions and customers, such as sales forecasting and attracting more customers (David at al., 2023).
Research Methodology
This study adopts a quantitative approach using a questionnaire to obtain data from officials in small and medium enterprises. It aims to investigate the factors associated with the adoption of AI in the field of e-commerce, while considering the relevant literature to improve the study results. Data for this study were collected by distributing an online questionnaire to a sample of 183 decision-makers and managers in small and medium-sized enterprises in Iran working in e-commerce. The sample focused on store owners and supervisors regarding their main occupations. The e-store owners were contacted through visits to the small and medium-sized enterprises, as well as through phone calls, WhatsApp, and email to encourage participation in the survey.
Research Findings
Structural equation modeling was used to analyze the data collected from the questionnaires and test the hypotheses. Based on the data analysis, the results of structural equation modeling showed that entrepreneurial orientation has a positive and significant effect on the adoption of AI-based e-commerce. The findings indicate that dynamic capabilities have a very positive and significant effect on the adoption of AI-based e-commerce. These findings emphasize that dynamic capabilities, such as the ability to learn quickly, adaptability, and continuous innovation in SMEs, can play a key role in the adoption and effective use of AI-based e-commerce. The results showed that the adoption of AI-based e-commerce has a positive and significant impact on the business performance of SMEs. This indicates a very strong and significant effect of this relationship. These findings emphasize that the adoption of new technologies such as AI can significantly improve the business performance of companies. In particular, companies that exploit AI-based e-commerce will be able to optimize their processes, reduce costs, and generally achieve economic advantages in competition with other companies.
Conclusion
This research shows that SMEs need to develop dynamic capabilities and strengthen entrepreneurial orientation to successfully adopt AI in e-commerce. Dynamic capabilities, as the ability of an organization to reconfigure resources, adapt to changes, and exploit new opportunities, are considered key factors in the adoption of new technologies. The results of the present study emphasize that companies with stronger dynamic capabilities are able to integrate AI into their business processes more effectively, which leads to improved organizational performance.
From a practical perspective, this research shows that in order to optimally utilize AI, small and medium-sized enterprises should focus on developing their dynamic capabilities and strengthening an entrepreneurial culture. Investing in employee training, developing agile strategies, and creating support structures for innovation can help to more effectively adopt this technology. From a theoretical perspective, this study highlights the role of dynamic capabilities and entrepreneurial orientation in the adoption of digital technologies and establishes a link between the strategic management, entrepreneurship, and digital transformation literature.
The present study aimed to provide a model to investigate the factors affecting the adoption of artificial intelligence in e-commerce by small and medium-sized enterprises in Iran. The results of this study are consistent with the results of Salah et al., (2024), Wei et al., (2022), Palataeka et al., (2023), Yang et al., (2024), Stalings et al., (2024), and Cabrit et al., (2024). The findings show that small and medium-sized enterprises need to develop dynamic capabilities and strengthen entrepreneurial orientation to successfully adopt artificial intelligence in e-commerce. Dynamic capabilities, as the ability of the organization to reconfigure resources, adapt to changes, and take advantage of new opportunities; are considered key factors in the adoption of new technologies.
Finally, this study suggests directions for future research; including examining the impact of other organizational and environmental factors on AI adoption, analyzing the role of government policies and financial support in the development of digital technologies, and studying the long-term impact of AI on the sustainability of small and medium-sized businesses. Also, conducting comparative research across industries can help to better understand the structural and strategic differences in the adoption of this technology. 

The effect of artificial intelligence technology on the development of entrepreneurship with the mediating role of entrepreneurship education

Volume 3, Issue 1, Spring 2024, Pages 86-105

https://doi.org/10.22034/jnamm.2024.454730.1052

rasol mohamadi, seyed reza mousavi fard, bijan rezaee, mahdi hosseinpour

Abstract Abstract The purpose of this research is to investigate the effect of artificial intelligence technology on the development of entrepreneurship with the mediating role of entrepreneurship education. The research is applicable in terms of purpose, descriptive- survey in terms of nature, and of casual type. The statistical population of the research was managers and employees of start-up business companies in Kermanshah province. The sample size is 193 people and sampling method is random cluster. The data collection method was field collection, and the tools used were entrepreneurial development questionnaires (Antonik and Hiserich, 2003), artificial intelligence technology (adapted from Rahimi and Akbari research, 1402), and entrepreneurship training (researcher-made). The method of data analysis was descriptive statistics and inferential statistics (structural equation modeling), using Spss26 and Amos24 software. Sobel's test (t-statistic) was used to investigate the mediator variable. The findings showed that artificial intelligence technology has a significant effect on entrepreneurship development by 86%; and on entrepreneurship education by 83%. Also, entrepreneurship education predicts 11% of the changes resulting from entrepreneurship development. The results indicate that artificial intelligence technology has an impact on the development of entrepreneurship with the mediating role of entrepreneurship education in the start-up businesses of Kermanshah province. Extended Abstract Introduction The development of entrepreneurship is a complex, long-term and inclusive process that plays a significant role in the economic growth and development of countries. Today, entrepreneurship has become the most important and strategic economic tool of advanced societies. In fact, economic growth and development of countries depends on entrepreneurs and entrepreneurial activities. Therefore, the need to achieve economic development and progress is to pay special attention to the development of entrepreneurship (Zali & Razavi, 2008). The development of entrepreneurship requires serious determination and necessary knowledge in businesses; many influential factors can be listed that may improve the development of entrepreneurship. One of these factors that has created a global revolution today is the use of artificial intelligence technology in start-up businesses and entrepreneurship. In today's world, technological advances are one of the most fundamental factors in shaping society's transformations in all economic, cultural, political and social fields. Human dependence on technology is such that some experts such as Max Tegmark say: "Without technology, the extinction of us humans, on a cosmic scale of tens of billions of years, will happen soon" (Tegmark, 2017). One of the factors that can increase the effect of artificial intelligence technology on the development of entrepreneurship as a mediator is entrepreneurship education. Today, it is accepted that the progress and survival of any society and business depends on the quality and efficiency of the education of that society; and educational courses have an important mission in producing knowledge and preparing new businesses to assume leadership and responsibility in a competitive, complex and changing world (Escorcia et al., 2022). According to the stated contents, this research tries to answer the question: what is the effect of artificial intelligence technology on the development of entrepreneurship with the mediating role of entrepreneurship education? Theoretical framework Artificial intelligence Artificial intelligence is a multidisciplinary and interdisciplinary field grown tremendously since the introduction of handheld computers in the 1950s. This field has the potential to transform various industries, and is defined as any theory, method, or approach that helps machines, especially computers, in analyzing, simulating, exploiting, and exploring human intellectual processes and behaviors (Lund et al, 2023). Entrepreneurship training Entrepreneurship education refers to all activities that aim to develop entrepreneurial mentality, attitude and skills in a range of cases such as idea generation, start-up, growth and innovation (Nvello et al, 2015). Entrepreneurship training is an activity that is used to transfer the knowledge and information needed to start and manage a business, and it will increase, improve, and develop the attitudes, skills, and abilities of non-entrepreneurs (Naeiji & Ebrahimi, 2017). From the viewpoint of literature, in the simplest definition, entrepreneurship can be considered as the use of skills to bring innovation to business or to develop new businesses (Shetty et al, 2021). The first issue raised in entrepreneurship research and start-up business development was the emphasis given to capacities, specific assets, and the unit of new economic activities. Ownership, capabilities and assets can be a sign of successful growth of a business. Intelligence in entrepreneurship is a technology-driven process for collecting, integrating, analyzing and presenting business information (Mehdi Sasan, Bakhshandeh, 2022). Therefore, the first emphasis is research on artificial intelligence as a technology-based software, and the use of this technology in the global economy is increasing day by day. The use of artificial intelligence allows start-up businesses to improve economic conditions and business growth (Dondapati et al, 2022). Yerevani et al, (2024) conducted a systematic review of the impact of artificial intelligence on the world's educational systems. This research has been done with a systematic review of 26 scientific research articles, 5 books and 13 reference sites. The results showed that artificial intelligence has a comprehensive role and importance in education systems. In the field of education by artificial intelligence, there are many successful projects and systems (GPT, etc.) that have facilitated the improvement of the teaching and learning process. Gofman & Jin (2024) in a study entitled Artificial Intelligence, Education and Entrepreneurship concluded that students of disadvantaged universities founded fewer AI startups and attracted less funding. Also, the departure of professors from universities reduces the knowledge of artificial intelligence of startups, which seems to be an important factor for the successful formation of startups and attracting capital. Research methodology The current research is applicable in terms of purpose, descriptive- survey in terms of nature, and of casual type. The method of collecting information is library-based, and the tool used is note-making. The statistical population of the research is managers and employees of start-up businesses in Kermanshah province. The population size was 385 people and the sample size was determined to be 193 people based on Cochran's formula. Also, the sampling method of this research was random cluster. The data collection method was field-collection, and the tools used are a) Entrepreneurship Development Questionnaire (Antonik & Hisrich, 2003), b) Artificial Intelligence Questionnaire (Rahimi & Akbari, 2023), and c) Entrepreneurship Education Questionnaire (researcher-made). Research findings Spss and Amos software were used in this section. The statistical findings showed that the research hypotheses were confirmed with a significance level of less than 0.05, and the effect of artificial intelligence technology on entrepreneurship development is 86% and on entrepreneurship education is 83%. Also, the effectiveness of entrepreneurship education on entrepreneurship development was calculated as 11%. The results of the general hypothesis of the research were done using the Sobel test (t statistic). The results of this test are significant with a coefficient of 2.258 at a level of 1.96 and a significance level of 0.001, and it shows that artificial intelligence technology with the mediating role of entrepreneurship education has an impact on the development of entrepreneurship in start-up companies in Kermanshah province. Conclusion Artificial intelligence technology can help greatly in the process of entrepreneurship education. Artificial intelligence makes entrepreneurship education learners use the updated information and resources in this field to make proper use of it in their business process. Therefore, it can be concluded that artificial intelligence is an effective and applicable factor in entrepreneurship education. The statistical results obtained indicate that artificial intelligence has an effect of 83% on the changes resulting from entrepreneurship education. The results of structural equation modeling and the obtained fit indices are proof of this claim. The results obtained are aligned with the results of Yerevani et al., (2024), Moradzadeh (2022), Gafman & Jane (2024), Chen et al., (2024) and Kissinger et al, (2021). Today, a business is successful if it has enough information and knowledge and can develop its entrepreneurship and business through education. Therefore, entrepreneurship training is essential for start-up businesses and entrepreneurship development. The development of entrepreneurship will be faster when the necessary trainings have been implemented and the entrepreneurs have learned these trainings well and implement them in their business. The statistical results obtained indicate that entrepreneurship education responds to 11% of the changes resulting from entrepreneurship development. The obtained results are consistent with the results of Dahdahjani (2019) and Agha Mohammadi and Abdulahi (2015). The results of the general hypothesis of the research regarding the effect of artificial intelligence technology on the development of entrepreneurship with the mediating role of entrepreneurship education were confirmed with the Sobel test. According to the results obtained for the first hypothesis, it is suggested to identify the advantages and disadvantages of artificial intelligence in the entrepreneurial system and pay special attention to its strengths. In line with the results of the second hypothesis, it is suggested that the threats resulting from the implementation of artificial intelligence in entrepreneurship education and entrepreneurship development should be reduced as much as possible. And finally, in line with the results of the third hypothesis, it is suggested that artificial intelligence be considered as one of the new and practical technologies in start-up businesses.

Marketing Management

Improving employee performance through internal marketing and organizational learning: The mediating role of organizational innovation

Volume 4, Issue 1, Spring 2025, Pages 1-21

https://doi.org/10.22034/jnamm.2025.524617.1093

neda zarin negar, Mohsen Najafi, fattaneh Hosseinzadeh bajgiran

Abstract Abstract
The present study investigated improving employee performance through internal marketing and organizational learning: the mediating role of organizational innovation. This research is applicable in terms of purpose, quantitative in terms of method, and of descriptive-survey type. The statistical population in this study is 116 food exporting companies in Mashhad, and using the Cochran formula, the sample size was estimated to be 86 companies; for this purpose, a questionnaire was distributed among and completed by the managers of these companies using simple random sampling method. In order to analyze the data, structural equation modeling test and other statistical tests based on SPSS and Pls software were used. The validity of the research variables was measured through confirmatory factor analysis. Also, the reliability of the research variables has shown that Cronbach's alpha for research variables including internal marketing, performance, organizational innovation, and organizational learning has been obtained as 0.909, 0.935, 0.940, and 0.901 respectively, which indicates the desired reliability of the research tool. The research findings have shown that organizational learning and internal marketing are effective on employee performance and organizational innovation mediates its effect.
Introduction
In today's world, human resources are recognized as the most important resource of organizations and attracting and retaining efficient forces is considered a vital competitive advantage (Chaudhary & Sharma, 2024). With rapid environmental changes, traditional management tools have become ineffective and the need for flexible and learning structures to respond to changes is felt more than ever. Optimal human resource performance is a necessary condition for the success of organizations, as it allows managers to focus on macro strategies (Organ, 2020). Two key factors in improving employee performance are organizational learning and internal marketing. Organizational learning helps organizations survive in a competitive environment by producing knowledge and continuously reviewing methods. On the other hand, internal marketing, by looking at employees as internal customers, creates effective relationships and improves organizational performance by increasing job satisfaction and motivation (Ocharo & Kinyua, 2021). Also, organizational innovation, especially in times of crisis and intense competition, plays a decisive role in the success of organizations and helps managers allocate resources optimally (Quispe et al., 2024). This issue is doubly important in food trading companies that face export challenges and strict standards. Therefore, in today's dynamic and uncertain environment, organizations need a flexible, learning, and innovative structure to meet stakeholder expectations. Based on the above, this study examines the question: do internal marketing and organizational learning through innovation have a significant impact on employee performance?
Theoretical foundations
Innovation and organizational innovation
Leticia Santos et al., (2022) consideres innovation as the tendency of a company or organization to participate in and support new ideas, pioneer in technology, conduct research, development, and other creative activities aimed at developing new products, services, and processes. On the other hand, organizational innovation encompasses a wide range of actions and activities aimed at facilitating and achieving innovative results in the organization. This type of innovation can be related to a product, device, system, process, policy, program, or service (Chen & et al., 2019).
Internal Marketing
Internal marketing means that companies should seriously invest in the quality of performance and capabilities of their employees. This is especially important for people who are directly in contact with customers, and these people need to be trained effectively. Also, all support staff should work together and work as a team to satisfy customers (Corrin & et al., 2022).
Organizational Learning
Organizational learning is a dynamic process that enables an organization to adapt quickly to changes. This process involves the production of new knowledge, skills, and behaviors. Organizational learning is the main way to create knowledge work and improve the efficiency of the organization; therefore, a successful organization must be dynamic in learning (Okolie, 2024).
Research Background
Bikzadeh Abbasi & Kaneshloo (2024) conducted a study titled: Investigating the Effect of Marketing Research on Improving Organizational Innovation. The results obtained indicate that marketing research has a positive and significant effect on improving organizational innovation in the United Nations Credit Institution. Khajeh Saeed & Sattarii (2024) conducted a study titled: The Effect of Marketing Capabilities on the Financial Performance of Exporting Companies. The results of this study showed that financial resources, information resources, and relational resources have a significant effect on the financial performance of exporting companies. Patwary et al., (2022) conducted a study aimed at investigating the role of knowledge management (KM) practices on performance and innovation. The findings indicate that KM has a positive effect on innovation performance among Malaysian hospitality employees. This study also shows that organizational learning and organizational creativity significantly mediate the relationship between KM and innovation performance.
Research Methodology
The present study is applicable in terms of purpose, and descriptive-survey in terms of method. The statistical population in this study is 116 food exporting companies in Mashhad, and the sample size was estimated to be 86 companies using the Cochran formula; for this purpose, a questionnaire was distributed among the managers of these companies and completed by them, through a simple random sampling method. In order to collect data, a questionnaire with 36 items related to the research variables was used. Also, in order to analyze the data in this study, the structural equation modeling technique and other statistical tests were used through SPSS and Smart PLS software. Face validity was used to confirm validity and Cronbach's alpha coefficient criterion was used to confirm reliability.
Findings
The findings of this study are presented in the form of 7 hypotheses, all of which were confirmed.
 Internal marketing has a positive and significant effect on employee performance.
 Organizational learning has a positive and significant effect on employee performance.
 Organizational innovation has a positive and significant effect on employee performance.
 Internal marketing has a positive and significant effect on organizational innovation.
 Organizational learning has a positive and significant effect on organizational innovation.
 Internal marketing has a positive and significant effect on employee performance with the mediating role of organizational innovation.
 Organizational learning has a positive and significant effect on employee performance with the mediating role of organizational innovation.
Discussion and Conclusion
The present study aimed to improve employee performance through internal marketing and organizational learning: the mediating role of organizational innovation (case study: food exporting companies in Mashhad). The findings of this study are consistent with the research of Chaubey et al., (2024), Laksono (2023), Imani et al., (2015), Karimi et al., (2021), and Gholipour et al., (2021). In the following, and based on the research findings, the following suggestions are presented:
 Internal marketing

Designing motivational systems to increase job satisfaction
Improving organizational communications and clarifying processes
Paying attention to the needs of employees as internal customers

Organizational learning

Holding continuous training courses
Creating an organizational knowledge bank of successful and unsuccessful experiences
Encouraging employees to share knowledge

 Developing innovation

Creating a safe space for presenting new ideas
Forming cross-departmental innovation teams
Investing in new technologies

 Coordinating strategies

Integrating internal marketing with innovation programs
Facilitating knowledge exchange between different units
Practical support for innovative ideas

 Human resource management

Mapping a career path for employees
Promoting a culture of continuous learning
Linking individual and organizational goals 

Identifying factors affecting sustainable consumption: a hybrid approach

Volume 1, Issue 1, March 2023, Pages 1-19

https://doi.org/10.22034/jnamm.2023.383330.1001

Kobra Sadeghi Dezaki, Abdol-Qayyum Azmoodeh Rad, siyavosh alirezaei

Abstract Responsible and sustainable consumption is considered one of the important aspects of sustainable development, which depends on achieving long-term economic growth compatible with environmental and social needs. In fact, the level of people's awareness about the environment and their mental self-awareness is directly related to the amount and type of consumption by the consumer. The more consumers give importance to environmental issues, the more resistance they have in consuming products that are in conflict with it, and this point of view accurately shapes consumer perception and behavior, so a producer, in addition to paying attention to issues related to the category Sustainable consumption must also take into account the factors that affect consumer behavior. The purpose of this research was to analyze the factors influencing sustainable consumption with metacombination method in Shahrekord convenience stores. Due to the comprehensive approach of the concept of conscious consumption presented by Sheth and colleagues (2011) and Lim (2017), this research tries to expand and complete the presented concept with a review study. Therefore, by considering the two aspects of conscious mental structure and conscious behavior for conscious consumption, the dimensions of a conscious mental structure that can lead to the occurrence of conscious behavior in the field of consumption are identified.

Strategic Management

From Survival to Evolution: A Comprehensive and Dynamic Model of Organizational Resilience for Iranian SMEs in Permacrisis Ecosystem Using Meta-synthesis

Volume 4, Issue 3, Autumn 2025, Pages 43-73

https://doi.org/10.22034/jnamm.2025.561784.1215

Ehsan Mirzadeh, seyed morteza ghayour baghbani, Morteza Rojuee, Saeed Jafari titkanloo

Abstract Abstract This study aims to design a comprehensive and dynamic model to explain organizational resilience in Iranian small and medium-sized enterprises. Given that these companies operate in a unique ecosystem of permanent crisis, traditional resilience models based on cross-sectional shocks seem inadequate to explain their dynamics. This research is exploratory and theoretical in nature and is based on the interpretive paradigm. A mixed methodological approach including metasynthesis as the main method and bibliometric analysis as a complementary method was used, and bibliometric data were extracted from 953 articles in Scopus and analyzed with VOSviewer software. After a systematic search of reliable databases and screening, 67 key articles were selected and synthesized and integrated through a content analysis process. Qualitative data analysis led to the identification of 460 unique conceptual codes that were categorized into 15 organizing themes and 5 overarching themes including: “1. Drivers and enabling factors, 2. Multilevel capabilities (individual/entrepreneurial, organizational, network/institutional), 3. Dynamic process cycle (anticipation, exposure, learning), 4. Resilient strategies (defensive, adaptive, offensive), and 5. Heterogeneous outcomes”. The main finding of the research is “A dynamic and multilevel model of organizational resilience in a permanent crisis environment,” which conceptualizes resilience as an evolutionary meta-capability. This research presents the first comprehensive and dynamic theoretical framework to explain resilience in the Iranian perma-crisis ecosystem, and its main innovation lies in conceptualizing resilience as an evolutionary process for the strategic transition from survival to evolution and showing the mechanisms of this transition. Introduction The business landscape is witnessing a paradigm shift as it enters an era of constant turmoil and unpredictable disruptions. This environment, described as the “Woka world”, has seriously challenged the fundamental principles of traditional strategic management. In these circumstances, the survival and sustainable growth of organizations requires a capacity beyond short-term resistance, known in the literature as the concept of organizational resilience (Chi et al., 2025). The understanding of the concept of resilience has evolved from the traditional “go back” perspective to the new “leap forward” paradigm, emphasizing strategic learning and transformation (Hernes et al., 2025). However, the existing literature suffers from three gaps: theoretical fragmentation and lack of integrated models, a homogeneous view of resilience pathways, and a lack of sensitivity to context. Much of the research has examined resilience in response to episodic crises and has not been able to explain it in the context of a permanent crisis (permacrisis), a structural situation in which multiple and intertwined crises have become the norm (Maalouf et al., 2025). This concept accurately describes the unique nature of the Iranian business environment. Iranian companies, especially small and medium-sized enterprises, operate in a multi-crisis ecosystem shaped by a combination of factors such as economic and institutional instability, international sanctions, social unrest, geopolitical tensions, and infrastructure challenges (Shabani et al., 2025). Numerous pieces of evidence, including the National Business Environment Monitoring Reports and the unprecedented rise in the Uncertainty Index, confirm this turbulent ecosystem. These conditions render resilience models developed in more stable environments ineffective. At the heart of this ecosystem, SMEs, as the driving force of the economy, face a paradox: on one hand, they are more vulnerable due to resource constraints; and on the other hand, they have a higher potential for agility due to their flexibility (Koporcic et al., 2025). How this potential is activated in Iran’s high-risk context is a question that, despite valuable domestic research, still requires a comprehensive model based on systematic knowledge synthesis. Accordingly, this study aims to design and present a comprehensive, dynamic, and multi-level model of organizational resilience for SMEs in Iran’s perma-crisis ecosystem. This article conceptualizes resilience as an evolutionary meta-capability for the transition from survival to evolution, moving beyond a static perspective. To achieve this goal, this research uses meta-synthesis and bibliometric analysis to systematically synthesize previous researches to arrive at a new and context-sensitive theoretical framework and answer the fundamental question: "What are the dimensions and components of a comprehensive model of organizational resilience in Iranian small and medium-sized enterprises in a permanent crisis ecosystem?" The theoretical framework Organizational Resilience Hepfer & Lawrence (2022) defines resilience as “the ability of an organization to anticipate, respond to, recover from, and learn from adversity”. Organizational resilience is a multilevel phenomenon. The existing literature generally distinguishes three key levels of resilience: individual, organizational, and network/institutional (Hillmann & Guenther, 2021). 1. Individual level: This level focuses on the psychological resilience of employees, managers, and especially entrepreneurs (Hartmann et al., 2022). In the context of small and medium-sized enterprises, the individual resilience of the entrepreneur plays a vital and pivotal role in guiding the entire organization’s response to a crisis (Leonelli et al., 2024). 2. Organizational level: This level, which is the main focus of this research, addresses the resources, processes, capabilities, and structures that allow the entire organization to cope with disruptions (Barasa et al., 2018). 3. Network/Institutional Level: This level examines resilience beyond the boundaries of an organization and focuses on the quality of the institutional environment, supportive policies, and the organization’s relationships with external actors and stakeholders (Koporcic et al., 2025). Koporcic et al. (2025) in a comprehensive umbrella review, identified key barriers to resilience in SMEs as constraints related to firm size and greater vulnerability to shocks, financial constraints and ineffective leadership and lack of crisis management skills; and key coping strategies included business continuity planning, organizational culture, technology adoption, proactive manufacturing, and strategic cooperations. De Waal et al. (2025) identified four heterogeneous resilience paths (incomplete recovery and survival, performance recovery, leapfrogging, explosive leap) in a longitudinal study of Ukrainian companies in war conditions, which shows that survival in critical conditions is itself a form of resilience. Research Methodology This research is exploratory and theoretical in nature, based on an interpretive paradigm, and uses the meta-synthesis and bibliometric analysis methods. Research Findings Data analysis was conducted using the meta-synthesis method as the main method and bibliometric analysis as a complementary method. Also, bibliometric data were extracted from 953 articles in Scopus and analyzed with VOSviewer software. After a systematic search of reliable databases and screening, 67 key qualitative and conceptual studies were finally selected and synthesized and integrated through a content analysis process. The results showed that 460 conceptual codes were classified into 15 organizing themes and 5 overarching themes including “drivers and enabling factors, multilevel capabilities, dynamic process cycle, resilient strategies, and heterogeneous outcomes.” The main finding of the research is “A dynamic and multilevel model of organizational resilience in a permanent crisis environment”. This model conceptualizes resilience as an evolutionary meta-capability that emerges from the dynamic interaction between the reservoir of multilevel capabilities and the flow of a continuous learning cycle and includes the following elements: 1) drivers and enabling factors (permanent crisis context); 2) the core of resilience including multilevel capabilities (individual/entrepreneurial, organizational, and network/institutional) and a dynamic process cycle (anticipation, exposure, learning); and 3) heterogeneous outcomes (from survival to explosive mutation). This model operates through strategic choices (defensive, adaptive, offensive) and evolves over time with feedback loops and an “evolutionary learning spiral”. Conclusion The present study aimed to provide a comprehensive and dynamic model of organizational resilience in Iranian SMEs in a permanent crisis ecosystem using a meta-synthesis method. The findings of this study are fully consistent with studies that emphasize the pivotal role of the leader in SMEs (Leonelli et al., 2024; Branicki et al., 2018). However, this model goes further and shows that leader resilience (including strategic intelligence and managerial competencies) is not only a driver, but also the main catalyst for activating capabilities at other levels. At the organizational level, this model is consistent with the main literature by highlighting capabilities such as agility, learning culture and digital transformation (Georgescu et al., 2024; Dowlatabadi, 2025) and shows that organizational capabilities are a platform for institutionalizing individual-level experiences and intuitions and transforming individual learning into organizational memory. At the network level, this model is also consistent with the findings of researchers by emphasizing strategic partnerships and resource dependency management (Koporcic et al., 2025). In the Iranian context, where formal institutions are weak and unreliable, informal and trust-based networks (social capital) become an alternative infrastructure for business. At the macro level, the resilience of small and medium-sized enterprises affects the resilience indicators of society, and supportive government policies can lead to strengthening the country's business ecosystem. This research, by moving beyond simplistic models, attempted to open the black box of resilience in the unique context of Iran's permanent crisis.

The effect of green marketing on green repurchase intention (mediating and moderating role of green marketing strategies)

Volume 3, Issue 4, Winter 2025, Pages 44-66

https://doi.org/10.22034/jnamm.2025.521082.1089

Abbas Ghaedamini Harouni, Mahsan Hemtizadeh, Khatoon Hashemipour

Abstract Abstract The present study was conducted with the aim of investigating the effect of green marketing on green repurchase intention with the mediating role of green marketing strategies. The research is applicable in terms of its purpose, descriptive in terms of the nature of the data, and of the correlation type (structural equation modeling). The statistical population of this study consists of consumers of green products of HB Board Company. The desired information was collected from the study sample using an online questionnaire. Given that the number of statistical population in this study is large and uncertain, the Cochran formula for unlimited populations was used to determine the sample size, and the number of sample members was selected by considering the estimated number of 384 people as non-probability sampling, known as convenience sampling. The research tool was standard questionnaires, and the validity of the questionnaires was examined based on content, face and construct validity, and after the necessary terms, the validity was confirmed; on the other hand, the reliability of the questionnaires was estimated by Cronbach's alpha method; all variables above 0.7 Data analysis was performed at two descriptive and inferential levels, including structural equation modeling. The results showed that green marketing positively affected all green outcomes; and green advertising, brand loyalty, brand equity and brand innovation had a positive effect on repurchase intention. However, a significant moderating effect of green awareness on green brand equity and green repurchase intention was not found. Introduction Consumers' satisfaction with their green purchases is influenced by their level of satisfaction. As a contemporary approach, green marketing has important implications for consumers' perceptions and behavioral tendencies. The evolving strategies in green marketing emphasized its potential for sustainable branding. The impact of green marketing tools highlighted on purchasing behavior, reinforcing the effectiveness of green advertising in fostering positive consumer perceptions. In the case of brand loyalty, green advertising and brand innovation positively affect brand loyalty and encourage repeat purchases. They emphasized the critical role of green brand equity in shaping repurchase intention. They stated that green brand effects and trust significantly underlie green brand equity, which in turn, stimulates repurchase. Green brand innovation enhances loyalty, especially when consumers are well informed about environmental issues, and increases the chances of green repurchase. While there is a growing literature on green marketing and its impact on consumer behavior, several gaps still need to be addressed. First, the integrated effects of green marketing, advertising, brand loyalty, equity value, and innovation on consumer repurchase intention remain to be investigated (Chen et al., 2020). Second, the potential moderating role of green awareness in strengthening or weakening the relationship between green advertising, brand loyalty, equity, innovation, and repurchase intention needs further research (Alemsiyah et al., 2021). Third, while green satisfaction is known to be pivotal in influencing consumer behavior (Chen et al., 2020), its moderating effect requires further empirical research, especially on the relationship between green marketing and green loyalty. This research is conducted in Iran (HB Board Company) and specifically focuses on the construction products sector. This sector was appropriately selected due to its significant contribution to the Iranian economy and environmental degradation. Although the direct effect of green marketing on green advertising, green brand loyalty, green equity, green brand innovation, and consumer repurchase intention has been studied, the potential moderating effects of green awareness and green satisfaction on these relationships still need to be investigated. Understanding these moderating effects is crucial for businesses seeking to optimize their green marketing strategies and foster stronger consumer loyalty to environmentally responsible brands; therefore, the present study identified gaps in the moderating role of green awareness in the relationships among green advertising, green brand loyalty, green equity, green brand innovation, and consumer repurchase intention that need to be better understood. There is a need to examine how different levels of green awareness affect these links to inform marketing strategies to better target repurchase intentions. Furthermore, the effect of green satisfaction as a moderating factor in the relationship between green marketing and green loyalty has not yet been fully explored. Gaining insight into this relationship can help businesses understand how consumer satisfaction with environmentally friendly products or services enhances green loyalty; therefore, the present study aims to investigate the effects of green marketing on consumer repurchase intention with the mediating role of green marketing strategies. Theoretical Framework Green Marketing and Green Repurchase Intention According to Rahbar and Vahid (2011), eco-labeling is a powerful tool to reduce knowledge asymmetry between consumers and sellers. Secondly, an eco-brand is a name, symbol or design attached to products not harmful to the surrounding ecosystem. Consumers may find it easier to distinguish eco-brands from other types of goods by using features that distinguish eco-brands from other types of products. According to Chatterjee (2009), consumers will be more motivated to choose environmentally friendly alternatives to products with a high level of environmental impact than those with a low level of environmental impact. Based on a previous survey conducted by Rahbar and Vahid (2011), consumers in Malaysia consider the categories of products made of glass, household cleaning products, aerosols, chemicals and plastics as non-green product classes that are highly harmful to the environment. Advertising about the environment helps to form consumer values ​​and transforms those values ​​into purchasing environmentally friendly items. According to Pancić (2023), environmental signals in commercials and product labeling sometimes influence the purchase choices of 70% of respondents. Research Methodology The present study is applicable in terms of purpose, descriptive in terms of data analysis, and of the correlation type (structural equation modeling). The statistical population of this study, consumers of green products in Iran, was collected using an online survey distributed via Google Forms. The present study surveyed consumers of HB Board, a company that markets green products. HB Board offers environmentally friendly building materials and uses sustainable resources. The survey was shared through various channels such as social media platforms and email invitations to reach a diverse sample of respondents. In addition, a consent letter was attached to the survey to increase the response rate. This letter provided information about the purpose of the study and assured the respondents that their participation was voluntary and that their responses would be kept confidential and used exclusively for research purposes. Considering that the statistical population of the present study is unlimited, the statistical sample size of the study was 384 people based on Morgan's table. Therefore, the present study used a non-probability sampling method known as convenience sampling to select participants, where the survey link was shared through social media platforms, online forums, and email invitations. Research Findings Data analysis was conducted at both descriptive and inferential levels, including structural equation modeling. The results showed that green marketing positively affected all green outcomes, and green advertising, brand loyalty, brand equity, and brand innovation had a positive effect on repurchase intention. However, it did not find a significant moderating effect of green awareness on green brand equity and green repurchase intention. Conclusion The present study aimed to investigate the effect of green marketing on green repurchase intention. The findings of the present study are consistent with previous studies that show that companies engaging in green marketing have a positive impact on various aspects of green consumer behavior, including green repurchase intention, green advertising, green brand loyalty, green brand equity, green innovation, and green branding (Mahmoud et al., 2024; Ramadan et al., 2024; Hu et al., 2024; Huang et al., 2024; Molana and Haryadi, 2024). This suggests that companies can focus on something other than increasing green awareness to improve their brand and increase consumer intention to repurchase their products. These findings can help companies develop more effective green marketing strategies, enhance their brand, and increase consumer willingness to repurchase their products. Given the varying levels of green awareness and global perceptions, it will be interesting to see whether these findings are consistent across cultures and regions.

business management

Identifying and prioritizing factors affecting the development of IoT-based businesses

Volume 4, Issue 1, Spring 2025, Pages 106-126

https://doi.org/10.22034/jnamm.2025.528979.1097

Zahra Ghanbari gheshlaghi, bizhan rezaei, Yosef Mohammadifar

Abstract Abstract
The main objective of this research is to identify and prioritize factors affecting the development of Internet of Things (IoT)-based businesses in Iran. This research is applicable in terms of purpose, and descriptive and survey in terms of methodology. It was conducted using content analysis method and in two qualitative and quantitative stages. In the qualitative stage, the required data were collected and analyzed by using semi-structured interviews with 8 experts in the field of information technology in Kermanshah science and technology parks and professors working in related universities. In this stage, 6 main factor categories were identified, including financial-economic, technological, cultural-social, political-legal, human, and managerial factors, as well as 22 sub-criteria. In the quantitative stage, the factors were prioritized using the Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) technique and Expert Choice software. The research findings showed that among the factors affecting the development of IoT-based businesses, the financial-economic factor has the highest priority, and the managerial factor has the lowest.
Introduction
The evolution of the Internet began with the connection of computers. Later, many computers were connected to each other, creating the World Wide Web. Then, mobile devices were able to connect to the Internet, which led to the mobile Internet technique. People began to use the Internet through social networks. Finally, the idea of ​​connecting everyday objects to the Internet was proposed, which led to IoT technology (Internet of Things). When the concept of such a connection emerged, various companies focused on it and tried to recognize its importance and began to identify its role and future aspects related to it. Then these companies began to invest in this area in different periods but at certain intervals (Korade et al., 2019). From an economic perspective, the Internet of Things can transform business models and provide new solutions for creating added value. Using data generated by IoT devices, digital businesses can better understand customer needs and optimize their products and services (Manyika et al., 2015). Due to the increased productivity resulting from IoT, many advanced countries such as the United States and Japan have developed special strategies for the development of this technology (Lee et al., 2019). According to research, the market size of IoT equipment in 2018 was nearly $2 billion, which is expected to reach more than $11 billion by 2026 (Wang et al., 2021). In Iran, several studies have examined the capabilities of the Internet of Things in various fields and emphasized its importance in economic development and improving productivity (Razavi et al., 2019). Given the increasing importance of the Internet of Things in the future of the digital economy, it is necessary to identify and analyze the key factors affecting the development of businesses related to this technology in a scientific and systematic manner in order to provide a basis for effective planning and policymaking. Despite the efforts made, a review of the research background shows that previous studies have had a limited focus on identifying the factors affecting the development of these types of businesses or have not conducted a comprehensive and structured study of them. The present study seeks to fill this gap and was designed and presented with the aim of providing a scientific framework for it; therefore, this study seeks to answer the question from a perspective different from previous studies: what are the factors affecting the development of IoT-based businesses and what is their priority?
Theoretical Framework
The Internet of Things is a conceptual paradigm that connects billions of Internet-enabled devices to exchange data between themselves and their environment and enable intelligent interactions. This paradigm is a digital-physical infrastructure that establishes a connection between the physical environment and digital systems (Whitmore, 2015).
Ajalli et al., (2023) examined how the Internet of Things affects human resource management in the Fourth Industrial Revolution. This study states that the Internet of Things, as a paradigm in which objects equipped with sensors, actuators, and processors communicate with each other, enables the creation of digital workflows and the simplification of human resource management processes. These findings are important for the development of IoT-based businesses, because using this technology to simplify processes and increase efficiency can help improve organizational performance, including in the field of human resource management.
Rezaei et al., (2022) examined the role of artificial intelligence in optimizing IoT data and its impact on Iranian businesses. The results of this study showed that integrating IoT and artificial intelligence can create a significant competitive advantage for businesses. This study used the Big Data analysis method to examine the effects.
Khan et al., (2024) in a study titled IoT Adoption in the Fourth Industrial Revolution showed that success in implementing IoT requires combining it with complementary technologies such as AI, big data, and cloud computing; and factors such as digital infrastructure, human resource skills, and cybersecurity are influential.
Prasetyo et al., (2023) studied the key success factors in implementing the Internet of Things in Indonesian automotive companies, and the results showed that factors such as strategic alignment with organizational goals, top management support, technology readiness, employee training, supply chain digitization, and the use of smart products play a decisive role in the success of implementing the Internet of Things.
Research Method
This research is applicable in terms of purpose, and descriptive and survey in terms of methodology. It was conducted using the content analysis method. The statistical population of this study included experts and specialists in the field of information and communication technology who were working in companies present in science and technology parks and university growth centers. The statistical sample in the qualitative section included 8 experts and specialists selected from the Kermanshah Science and Technology Park, Kermanshah Innovation Factory, and professors at Razi University of Kermanshah. The sampling method was snowball sampling. The statistical sample in the quantitative part consisted of 15 people, 6 of whom were the same participants in the interview and 9 others were selected from among the experts and specialists and added to them.
Research findings
After a careful and meticulous review of the interviews and content analysis, the main codes and concepts were extracted. The extracted codes were analyzed in the first coding stage and evaluated several times to extract categories from it. After identifying; 6 main factor categories and 22 sub-criteria was obtained, and in the next stage, the Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) method was used for quantitative analysis. 15 questionnaires were distributed among the experts, and pairwise comparisons were made with the Expert Choice software.
Conclusion
The results of this study are consistent with the findings of many previous studies. Specifically, the role of economic investment, the importance of technological infrastructure, and the effect of education and awareness on the adoption of the Internet of Things has also been confirmed in the studies of Hossain et al. (2015), Zhang et al. (2021), Li et al. (2020), and Khan et al. (2019). Also, the impact of sanctions and legal problems on the development of this technology in Iran is consistent with the results of Wang et al. (2020). Studies such as Camarinha-Matos et al. (2009) and Sadeghi et al. (2020) also consider the role of organizational cooperation in the success of IoT-based businesses to be similar to the findings of this study.
According to the results of this study, one of the solutions used in the world in the field of IoT businesses and their development is the use of venture capitalists. Despite economic and political problems at the international level prevent the introduction of new technologies and the country's synchronization with them, a country like Iran, which has a large workforce of experts in various fields of information technology; however, needs to find new ways to improve its economy and its position in the international arena; therefore, the importance of the Internet of Things for a country like Iran is obvious and can play a role in all fields. On the other hand, West Asia and North Africa are currently the second largest Internet of Things market, which the UAE, Saudi Arabia and Turkey have taken over. While Iran can be a developer and play a decisive role in the heart of this region and earn significant profits and thereby bypass sanctions.
Iran also has the largest number of metropolises in the Middle East, in which cities such as Tehran, Mashhad, Isfahan, etc. are always struggling with optimal urban management. Becoming smart cities, using smart cars and home appliances connected to the Internet of Things can play a significant role in improving and preventing the problems caused by them.
One of the most important reasons given for the incorrect and late functioning of Internet-connected objects is the slowness in sending them in these fields. By developing smart networks based on the Internet of Things, such problems can be overcome.
Businesses and stakeholders should pay special attention to investing in information and communication technology infrastructure to be able to benefit from the benefits of the Internet of Things. Businesses themselves should pay attention to continuous research and development in the field of the Internet of Things to be able to keep up with rapid technological changes. Designing and implementing training programs for employees and users can help improve their awareness and capabilities in using the Internet of Things.
Creating and strengthening cooperation networks between businesses and different organizations can help exchange information and resources. Businesses should also pay special attention to collecting and analyzing customer feedback to be able to better identify their needs and improve their services. 

Explaining the Model of Brand Selection and Development with Emphasis on the Role of Positioning Strategy in Yek-o-Yek Food Industries Company

Volume 3, Issue 3, Autumn 2024, Pages 223-241

https://doi.org/10.22034/jnamm.2025.550702.1175

Ahmad Akhlaghi, Ahmad Ahmad Askari, Abdullah Naami, Alireza Rousta

Abstract Abstract
This research aims to explain the pattern of brand selection and development with emphasis on the role of positioning strategy in Yek-o-Yek Food Industries Company. The research method is applicable in terms of purpose with quantitative approach. The statistical population of the research is all customers and consumers of Yek-o-Yek Company products, selected through non-random and available sampling method and 384 people according to Morgan table. The data collection method is a field method using a researcher-made questionnaire. The validity and reliability of the questionnaire were confirmed by construct validity, composite reliability, and Cronbach's alpha, respectively. The results of structural equations with smart pls3 software showed that the role of the creator factors (empowerment and commitment to customers, production capability, brand elements, marketing mix, competitive advantage, service differentiation), brand-oriented strategy (brand performance, brand positioning, brand values, brand perspectives, brand analysis and evaluation), on the outcomes (establishing brand position in the market, maintaining brand position among customers and the market, product and market development, brand promotion), strategies and actions (improving competitive position, market orientation, desirable mental image, intellectuality and strategic thinking of the senior manager) and the contextual condition variable (creating value for post-delivery services, structural prerequisites, integrating knowledge and organizational activities) were also confirmed as mediating variables and intervening condition variables (creating distinctive meanings of the organization's brand, awareness).
Introduction
The importance of positioning strategy in the process Brand selection can be viewed from the perspective of creating a sustainable distinction in the consumer's mind; successful positioning not only facilitates consumer choice, but also forms the basis for the development of brand identity and equity in the long term (Xiang et al., 2023). Emphasizing the strategic management and marketing literature, a brand is defined as a strategic intangible asset that creates a sustainable competitive advantage by creating a sustainable distinction in customer perception (Zhao et al., 2021). From the perspective of information economics, brands increase the efficiency of the consumer decision-making process by reducing information asymmetry and reducing search costs. (Dewi et al., 2020) At the organizational level, brand equity creates economic value through various mechanisms, including creating pricing power, increasing price elasticity of demand, and reducing vulnerability to competitors' promotional activities (Bilghihan et al., 2024). This value creation ultimately takes the form of more stable future cash flows and reduced Profit fluctuations and reflects itself in the company's financial statements. In addition, brands act as a defensive shield during periods of economic recession and increase the confidence factor in predicting long-term profitability by maintaining a loyal customer base (Azimi et al., 2021). From this perspective, strategic brand management is considered not as a cost, but as an investment in creating and maintaining dynamic organizational capabilities to create and capture economic value in the long term. Product or brand management is one of the key and important marketing capabilities. Brand plays a central role in marketing and has attracted much attention over the years (Ghorbani dolatabadi et al., 2021).
A brand is a name or symbol used to give identity to a product. In other words; a brand is one of the assets that can create great value for goods and services (Bernarto et al., 2020). Branding, as a complex cognitive-emotional mechanism, provides a fundamental foundation for shaping customer responses and developing effective marketing strategies by creating unique semantic associations between symbols, products and experiences, so that understanding the multiple dimensions of the brand and how they affect the consumer's mind and behavior helps organizations not only allocate their resources more optimally, but also create a lasting competitive advantage by creating sustainable differentiation (Azimi et al., 2021).
Taking advantage of its brand reputation, Yek-o-Yek company uses a brand development strategy to enter new areas and produce goods and services under the same brand name, which On one hand, it leads to the expansion and development of the company and on the other hand, it reduces the risk of brand image. However, this strategy is associated with the risk of damaging the brand image in the eyes of customers, and a wrong choice can reduce the brand equity in general. Therefore, the brand selection and development pattern in Yek-o-Yek Company should be planned with an emphasis on the positioning strategy and taking into account the brand development indicators in order to optimally benefit from its advantages. Considering the merits of the above, the current research seeks to answer the following question: What is the brand selection and development pattern with an emphasis on the role of positioning strategy in Yek-o-Yek Company?
Theoretical foundations
Brand development
Brand development refers to a set of activities and strategies that aim to enhance the value, recognition and loyalty to the brand in the market. The brand, as an intangible asset of the organization, not only shapes the mental image of consumers, but also plays an important role in purchasing decisions, customer loyalty, and competitive advantage (Merhabi et al., 2021).
Brand Performance
Brand performance indicates the extent to which a brand is successful in achieving its marketing and business objectives and assesses the effectiveness of brand development activities. Brand performance includes several indicators such as brand awareness, brand image, customer loyalty, market share, customer satisfaction, and brand equity. These indicators help an organization measure the impact of marketing and brand positioning strategies on consumer behavior and business success (Mashhadizadeh et al., 2024).
Brand Positioning
Brand positioning is a strategic process that determines how a brand is positioned in the consumer’s mind compared to its competitors. The main goal of positioning is to create a distinctive, valuable, and sustainable brand image that customers can easily identify and prefer. This process helps the organization highlight its competitive advantage and align marketing messages with the needs and expectations of the target market (Masoumi et al., 2023).
Haponen et al. (2021) titled “Expectations of Young Job Applicants’ Digital Identity in Relation to Corporate Social Media Brand Development Strategies” examined the role of employees’ digital image and social media in brand development of SMEs. The research methodology included a literature review and interviews with representatives of recruitment companies. The results showed that growth-oriented companies seek applicants with a prominent personal brand image.
Alshurideh et al. (2022) titled “The Role of Digital Marketing, Corporate Social Responsibility Policy and Green Marketing in Brand Development” examined the impact of digital marketing, CSR policies and green marketing on UK manufacturing companies. This study was quantitative and conducted with a closed questionnaire and a sample size of 404 companies. The results showed that the overall impact of these three factors on brand development was statistically significant and it was recommended that companies focus on environmental information disclosure, green innovation, green alliance and promotional activities.
Research Methodology
In this study, library studies and a systematic review of the research background were used to develop theoretical foundations, which enabled the extraction of a conceptual framework and indicators related to brand positioning and development strategies. To collect field data, a standard questionnaire based on the literature was used; distributed and implemented in the field among customers of the products of Yek-o-Yek company in the Shiraz metropolis. The statistical population of this study consisted of all consumers of the company's products in Shiraz, and the appropriate sample size was determined by the available sampling method and based on the Cochran formula, and questionnaires were distributed among them. The data obtained from the questionnaires were analyzed by statistical software.Research Findings
The research findings show that brand-creating factors, including brand values, mental image, brand performance, positioning, and perspectives, play an important and effective role in the formation of brand-oriented strategy. This brand-centric strategy, in turn, guides and directs strategies such as strategic thinking, positioning, image enhancement, and market orientation. In addition, the organizational context, including process integration and value creation, enhances the impact of strategies and facilitates their successful implementation. Finally, intervening strategies and conditions, such as meaning creation and awareness, affect the operational outcomes of the brand, including market development, brand promotion, and brand positioning, and increase brand equity and improve the overall performance of the organization.
Discussion and Conclusion
The research findings show that brand-creating factors, including brand values, performance analysis and evaluation, brand positioning, and vision have a significant impact on brand-centric strategy. These results are consistent with previous studies; for example, the studies of Merhabi et al. (2021) and Xi et al. (2020) also emphasize that values ​​and brand image play a key role in shaping marketing strategies and brand development. However, the present findings show that besides these factors, organizational perspective and analysis also directly influence brand strategies; a topic less addressed in some previous studies. Brand-centric strategy acts as a mediator between the factors that create and strategies and affects components such as strategic thinking, mental image, position improvement, and market orientation. These results are consistent with the results of Haponen et al. (2021) and Bilghihan et al. (2024), which show that brand-centric strategies align the organization's activities with market objectives and create competitive advantage. The main difference in the present study is that more emphasis is placed on the strategic role of brand-centric strategy in guiding a set of strategies and its effects on the brand's operational outcomes.
Furthermore, the findings show that contextual conditions such as integration and value creation have an impact on strategies. This result is consistent with the studies of Zarghami et al. (2022) who state that the internal environment of the organization and resource alignment enhance the success of brand strategies. Compared to previous studies, the present study shows that the role of these contextual conditions is not only facilitating, but also acts as a reinforcing factor in the impact of strategies on brand operational outcomes.
Also, strategies play a decisive role in achieving brand operational outcomes, including market development, brand promotion, and brand positioning. These results are consistent with the research of Lee et al. (2024) and Rezagholizad et al. (2024) who emphasize that effective implementation of strategies creates tangible consequences for business success and brand positioning. The point of difference of this research with previous studies is the examination of the effect of intervening factors such as meaning creation and awareness building, which shows that these conditions can strengthen or moderate the effect of strategies, a topic that has received less attention in previous research. 

Other topics related to business management, entrepreneurship, and marketing

Network Analysis Process (DANP) Sustainable Development Model Based on Quantum Management Approach

Volume 4, Issue 1, Spring 2025, Pages 310-331

https://doi.org/10.22034/jnamm.2025.383336.1004

Fatemeh hadavandi, Asadollah Mehrara, Seyedeh Shayesteh Varedi

Abstract Abstract The purpose of the present study is the Network Analysis Process (DANP) Sustainable Development Model Based on Quantum Management Approach. The research method is applicable-developmental in terms of its purpose, descriptive in terms of data collection, and quantitative in terms of implementation method. The statistical population of the study includes 10 municipal managers with at least 20 years of experience and their field of specialization is urban management, selected through purposive sampling. To collect data for the DEMETL section and the network analysis process for prioritizing variables, a standardized AHP paired comparison questionnaire was used and distributed to the statistical population of the study and, after completion, collected and analyzed. The DENP method (a combination of DEMETL and the Analytic Network Process (ANP)) was used to prioritize the effective factors. The results showed that urban infrastructure development, self-organization, urban governance and legislation, quantum knowledge, improving the quality of life, economic infrastructure development, social justice and participation, and improving environmental quality are in the first to eighth priority, respectively. Introduction The success of today's organizations depends on correct and efficient leadership that relies on influencing, guiding, directing, and streamlining the organization's activities, and the beliefs and convictions of employees. Quantum management, influenced by the quantum paradigm, has unique features that can meet the needs of leaders and organizations, especially government organizations, in today's ambiguous, uncertain, and rapidly changing conditions in order to achieve goals and organizational excellence (Madahiyan et al, 2021). The quantum perspective views the world as complex, living, highly interconnected, dynamic, describes as self-constructive and unpredictable, so that in this perspective, organizations must have a learning structure. Quantum management is a practice that, by creating human capacity, focuses more on the free and continuous interaction between the leader and employees, as well as the mutual influence of the internal dynamics of the organization with employees and vice versa; and by emphasizing the organization, it guides it towards a desirable future (Norouzzdeh et al., 2020). Following the development of cities, the speed of physical changes in the city, and the changing needs of citizens in various social and economic fields, comprehensive urban plans based on the principles of past years cannot meet the needs of cities; for this reason, such plans have been obsolete for decades and are not applicable, so their characteristics do not lead to improving the quality of living space in today's era (Ghadiri et al., 2021). The field of many urban researches is sustainable development, and the ideal attitude of urban planners and designers in designing sustainable cities is mainly on better living and reducing environmental crises (Bikdeli et al., 2018). Therefore, quantum management, which is a new management in line with the needs of the people and in harmony with the era of electronics and knowledge-based networks, can contribute significantly to sustainable development and a new approach to urban management. In this type of management, hierarchies and bureaucracies will be eliminated. Also, each person does what he specializes in, and the relationship is not the criterion for selecting individuals (Nazmfar et al., 2019). A quantum manager is a person who can make the best decision in the shortest time and has the power to resolve contradictions. In addition, he is a transparent and honest person and shares his decisions with the people and asks for their advice. Therefore, the solution to solving the current problems of urban management can be considered to be the use of strategic plans with the quantum management approach, and urban management should move towards creating small-scale structures with a wide scope of authority in the form of neighborhoods. Therefore, to prepare any plan for the development of the city, it is necessary to first of all gain knowledge. The knowledge in the urban planning system must be comprehensive and complete, so all dimensions of the city, including the city structure, uses, accesses, urban landscape, as well as the social, demographic, economic, managerial dimensions, etc., must be considered (Bahrini, 2022). Accordingly, the researcher addresses the main question: what is the network analysis process (DANP) of the sustainable development model based on the quantum management approach? Theoretical framework Sustainable development The concept of sustainable development means a process of change in which the exploitation of resources, the direction of investments, the orientation of technological development, and institutional changes are coordinated and increase the current and future potential to meet human needs. Sustainable development means the management and protection of basic resources and the introduction and application of technological advances and organizational structures through which human needs can be continuously and reasonably guaranteed for the present and future generations. (Roozbeh et al, 2023). Quantum Management Quantum management is a set of fully operational skills for managers appropriate for the characteristics of organizations in the last century. This metaphor for the behavior of managers is derived from quantum theory, which is derived from the field of physics. Quantum management increases the level of employee empowerment and at the same time provides the basis for consultation and synergy by employees and managers (Ali sofi & Salimi, 2023). Rasouli et al. (2024) examined the antecedents and consequences of professional competence of school administrators with an emphasis on environmental sustainability and sustainable development. The research findings showed that the professional competency model of managers includes the enablers of skill competency, management competency, and professional ethics and behavior competencies, manager development, social characteristics of managers, establishing work groups to improve performance and green competency, attitudinal competencies, knowledge competencies, educational competencies, knowledge-skill and technology commercialization competencies, high-work ethic, consumption pattern reform, participation in development, and movement toward national authority; which lead to the realization of the results of high-work ethic, consumption pattern reform, participation in development, movement toward national authority, diversity and pluralism management, and strengthening the relationship between humans and nature. Ali sofi & Salimi (2023) studied the effect of quantum management skills on readiness for change with the mediating role of organizational agility. The findings from the structural equation model showed that the standard coefficient between quantum management on readiness for change (0.19), quantum management on organizational agility (0.58), as well as readiness for change and organizational agility (0.64), and the indirect effect of quantum management on readiness for change (0.47) were significant.  Research Methodology The research method is applicable-developmental in terms of its purpose, descriptive in terms of data collection, and quantitative in terms of implementation method. The statistical population of the research includes 10 municipal managers with more than 20 years of experience and their field of specialization is urban management, selected through purposive sampling. A standardized AHP pairwise comparison questionnaire was used to collect data from the DEMETL section and the network analysis process to prioritize variables, and was distributed to the statistical population of the research and, after completion, collected and analyzed. Research findings The DANP method (a combination of DEMETL and the Analytical Network Process (ANP)) was used to prioritize the effective factors. The results showed that urban infrastructure development, self-organization, urban governance and legislation, quantum knowledge, improving the quality of life, economic infrastructure development, social justice and participation, and improving environmental quality are in the first to eighth priority, respectively. Conclusion The present study was conducted with the aim of the Analytical Network Process (DANP) model of sustainable development based on the quantum management approach. The results of this study are consistent with the results of Rasouli et al. (2024), Ali sofi & Salimi (2023), Roozbeh et al. (2023), Hajizadeh Majdi et al. (2023), Negahdarandeh & Anvari (2022), Nazarzadeh et al. (2021), Bahrini (2022), Shafiepour & Parhemat (2022), Dixon & Tewdwr-Jones (2021), and Rodríguez et al. (2019). Shafiepour & Parhemat (2022) showed that the characteristics of quantum management have a positive and direct impact on the three individual, social and organizational levels of human resource development, that is, by increasing quantum management techniques, the three individual, social and organizational levels of human resource development are improved. According to the results of the research, the following suggestion was made: -Reconstruction and modernization of worn-out water, electricity, gas and telecommunications networks to increase resilience to crises. -Creating comprehensive roadmaps for infrastructure development, taking into account population growth and future needs of the city. -Delegating more authority to local institutions and city councils to solve regional issues and encourage active citizen participation.

Keywords Cloud

Related Journals